Monday, July 25, 2011

Proposal: Fixed fix

Failed 1-6. Josh

Adminned at 28 Jul 2011 10:38:00 UTC

In the rule “species”, replace

Unidling Gladiators become Resting.

with

Unidling Gladiators are always considered to have been Resting when they became idle and will so be Resting when they unidle.

I realized that the previous fix would actually have exacerbated the problem. This one solves both issues cleanly.

Comments

Ely:

07-25-2011 19:43:27 UTC

imperial

Kevan:

07-26-2011 00:02:03 UTC

This seems quite strangely obtuse - when I idle, I remain Fighting, but when I unidle, I am then retroactively considered to have been Resting during that time? This has some odd effects, such as letting a player idle out while holding the Clingboom Cup, with them only dropping it retroactively when (if) they return.

Proposals are allowed to change gamestate directly - you could have just reproposed your previous proposal with “and every idle player is now considered to be Resting” on the end.

against

Doctor29:

07-26-2011 00:46:00 UTC

against I think…

Josh:

07-26-2011 06:16:18 UTC

against

Prince Anduril:

07-26-2011 15:06:27 UTC

against

Bucky:

07-26-2011 18:14:24 UTC

against