Wednesday, September 13, 2017

Proposal: Proposal:

timed out popular 7-2 with 2 def votes enacted by card

Adminned at 16 Sep 2017 17:20:03 UTC

Create a rule titled “Removing Nouns” with the text

A prince may pay 1 Stamina to remove a noun from the Katamari that is not the name of a Prince. This also reduces the stability of the Katamari by 1.

Comments

Sesquipedalian:

14-09-2017 00:23:19 UTC

Definitely an improvement for

Kevan: he/him

14-09-2017 00:33:09 UTC

for

VJRada:

14-09-2017 00:45:22 UTC

for

Cuddlebeam:

14-09-2017 00:48:34 UTC

for

Maldor: he/him

14-09-2017 01:32:46 UTC

The problem currently is that there is no way that the stability increases
imperial

card:

14-09-2017 01:49:45 UTC

[Maldor] see Trigon’s proposal for one that increases stability

derrick: he/him

14-09-2017 16:27:02 UTC

against

This should not reduce the stability. particularly if you’re allowed to take the first item in the katamari. If anything, it should increase stability.

This also allows infinite actions by decreasing the stability of the Katamari to 0.

derrick: he/him

14-09-2017 16:27:50 UTC

never mind on stability 0: it must be between 1 and 14. Good catch. but the other point still stands.

card:

14-09-2017 16:36:21 UTC

so far the proposals that included increasing stability have only done so by adding nouns to the katamari, I should think that removing nouns from the katamari would reduce stability.

Trigon:

14-09-2017 17:27:03 UTC

against

1. I don’t like the idea of being able to remove words from play whenever one feels like it.

2. If anything, this would increase the stability. Decreasing it should be only the result of a deliberate action to fix it.

Darknight: he/him

15-09-2017 13:37:35 UTC

imperial