Tuesday, November 05, 2019

Proposal: Friendly Fire - OFF

Fewer than a quorum not voting against. Failed 1 vote to 5 by Kevan.

Adminned at 06 Nov 2019 09:25:33 UTC

Change “Slash: Reduce any Adventurer’s HP by 10.”

Soul Slash: Reduce a Monster’s HP by a random number up to 20. Increase your own HP by half of that number, rounded up.

Change “Retreat: Until your next Battle Action, you may not be the target of Battle Actions.”

Retreat: Reduce your Merit by 10, to a minimum of 0. Until your next Battle Action, you may not be the target of Battle Actions.

“Claw: Reduce any Adventurer’s HP by 40.”

Claw: Reduce any Recovering Adventurer’s HP by 40.


Zero sum games should limit who can gang up on whom, somewhat.

Recovering Adventurers have just been fighting, so they should be the ones available for a Monster attack.



05-11-2019 20:01:05 UTC


Kevan: he/him

05-11-2019 21:09:30 UTC

imperial Claw is good but will discourage players from starting or joining battles. Feeling lukewarm about introducing dice.


05-11-2019 21:21:49 UTC

Dice is eh, I mostly just want there to be a self-interested reason to attack the Monster.

The Duke of Waltham: he/him

06-11-2019 00:02:25 UTC



06-11-2019 00:28:16 UTC

no dice against
there should’ve been at least a minimum to that move i.e. random number between 10 and 20.
also not liking forcing who the monster can hit, should be able to hit anyone but maybe do less damage depending on who it hits


06-11-2019 04:43:14 UTC

Rolling DICE10 and adding 10 seemed unnecessary. I don’t mind sometimes “missing” with a 1-3, and “crit-ing” other times.

Sure, less dmg for those not in combat would be another good way to limit it. I guess you’re going for thematic? I’m often just focusing on game theory aspects: how to prevent obvious teaming from being the dominant strategy, vs personal tactics. To each his own plans.


06-11-2019 06:04:15 UTC