Proposal: From the bottom to the top.
Reaches quorum 8-2 and is enacted. -coppro
Adminned at 28 May 2011 13:07:42 UTC
Replace all the text in Appendix Rule “Prioritisation” to:
If two parts of the Ruleset contradict each other, precedence shall be construed in the following order:
1. The Appendix has precedence over any Rule;
2. A Dynastic Rule has precedence over a Core Rule, unless that Core Rule explicitly says it can’t be overruled by a Dynastic Rule;
3. If both contradicting parts are a Core Rule, or if both of them are a Dynastic Rule, the part with more limited scope applies. (e.g. if the rules “Players may Kick each other” and “Players may not kick each other on Tuesdays” exist, and it is Tuesday, players may not Kick each other.)
4. If two parts with the same scope contradict each other, the negative rule applies. (e.g. with “Players may Punch a Spaceman on Friday” and “Player may not Punch Spacemen on Friday”, then Players may not Punch Spacemen on Friday.)
Add to the Rule “Calls for Judgement”:
This Rule may not be overruled by Dynastic Rules.
Here it comes.
I don’t like #1,#2, or #4.
I see no problems here.
Josh: he/they