Monday, September 04, 2017

Proposal: Western Reply [UN Resolution]

became unpopular with Support 95-126. failed by derrick.

Adminned at 05 Sep 2017 18:13:25 UTC

If Cuddlebeam is not part of the Western Bloc, change their Bloc to be Western.

If at least a majority of Western Bloc CICs have included the word “Forgive” in a comment to this proposal, then add to the Ruleset the following rule:

CICs can only be idled via mechanics described in “Idle CICs” in the Core Rules.

Otherwise: Idle all Eastern bloc CICs.

Comments

derrick: he/him

04-09-2017 16:37:51 UTC

for Forgive. We’re only trying to win.

Cuddlebeam:

04-09-2017 16:38:33 UTC

Forgive

Thunder: he/him

04-09-2017 16:43:29 UTC

Quorum 115:
67-19

Thunder: he/him

04-09-2017 16:43:51 UTC

against

Kevan: he/him

04-09-2017 16:44:31 UTC

against

Thunder: he/him

04-09-2017 16:46:41 UTC

67-55

Sesquipedalian:

04-09-2017 17:12:58 UTC

for Forgive

Thunder: he/him

04-09-2017 17:22:11 UTC

95-55

pokes:

04-09-2017 17:26:23 UTC

against Forgive

Maldor: he/him

04-09-2017 17:27:22 UTC

Oh good grief…
against

Sesquipedalian:

04-09-2017 17:31:15 UTC

95-89

Maldor: he/him

04-09-2017 17:36:18 UTC

Woah now, if I cant idle the west, you most certainly can’t idle the east

pokes:

04-09-2017 18:04:35 UTC

Note to admins, and to others who would write UN Resolutions when half of the CICs have 0 IE: if this gets enacted at 95-89 support, but 3-4 votes, I intend to CfJ it. In

A UN Resolution is only Popular if it has a Support that equals or exceeds UN Quorum

‘only ... if’ means to me that UN Quorum or above is necessary to achieve Popularity, but not sufficient (compare to “A UN Resolution is Popular if…”, which would be sufficient but not necessary). There are other conditions on Popularity, including the usual one vote per CIC condition, that I don’t see as being currently deactivated on UN Resolutions.

pokes:

04-09-2017 18:05:41 UTC

Well, I actually intended this comment to go on Western Takeover Take 2 but it still stands.

card:

04-09-2017 18:59:46 UTC

Seems silly to restrict idling as a mechanic in future dynasties.
against

Thunder: he/him

04-09-2017 21:54:42 UTC

95-126, quorum reached.