Thursday, August 11, 2011

Fweep: Blood on the Quad

Closed after 48 hours. The Foul was supported.

Adminned at 13 Aug 2011 07:33:04 UTC

When Josh harpooned me, he replaced my icon with that of an empty square. Yet under Rule 2.3.2 (Blood!), “Immediately after a Gladiator Dies, if the square where this death occurred is Empty, a Blood Pool is created there.”, so updating the square to be empty was an illegal modification. (This mistake has since been corrected by another player.)

Comments

Josh: he/him

11-08-2011 11:22:46 UTC

against A foul is “Attempting to make an illegal modification to the Arena wiki page or the GNDT stats” - this wasn’t illegal, just incomplete.

scshunt:

11-08-2011 11:24:11 UTC

for You modified IconKevan to IconEmpty; there was no legal way to do that given that his death immediately causes the creation of blood; you couldn’t have updated to the state in between.

Josh: he/him

11-08-2011 11:24:34 UTC

(“Immediately after” implies that they can be separate actions, rather than having to be the same one.)

Kevan: he/him

11-08-2011 11:25:17 UTC

But the Blood Pool is created “immediately after a Gladiator dies”. There is no legal way for an Arena square to change from “a Gladiator” to “an Empty Square”, if the Gladiator has been killed in this way.

Kevan: he/him

11-08-2011 11:27:28 UTC

(That was a simultaneous comment meant in reply to your original vote.)

Ely:

11-08-2011 20:06:30 UTC

for