Call for Judgment: Glossary says proposals aren’t art
Timed out 2 votes to 5. Failed by Kevan.
Adminned at 16 Oct 2011 12:59:50 UTC
Rule 3.2:
A proposal, call for judgment, or declaration of victory cannot simultaneously be any other type of official post unless otherwise specified by dynastic rules
Given the phrasing involved - it doesn’t apply to posts that aren’t proposals, CfJs or DoVs - I interpret this as “If another rule tries to make a post that is a proposal etc. also another type of official post, it fails to do so unless overruled by a Dynastic Rule”. As a glossary rule, the bias in this statement overrules dynastic rules that don’t explicitly overrule it.
Therefore, all Proposals since the start of the dynasty are not actually Works of Art. Remove all Acclaim resulting from exhibiting and critiquing Works of Art that are proposals - 2 from Bucky, and 1 from Kevan. Also, since this supplied 1 of the Acclaim that ais523 used to create a Faux Pas error, remove that error from the Faux Pas document and refund 2 Acclaim to ais523.
This CfJ also indirectly contests the alleged illegality of making CfJs for a similar reason, and upholds its own legality.
Bucky: