Continuing the theme of leaving out the inactive Thieves…

4st and I took on some Notoriety to get more in this Haul, so as compensation, I propose that JonathanDark gets the Unappraised Gem, 4st gets the Cloak and 3 Florins, Juniper.ohyegods gets the Helm because they don’t already have Possessions from previous Hauls, and Clucky, Desertfrog, JonathanDark, Juniper.ohyegods, and NadNavillus gets 2 Florins.

I agree with JonathanDark, with the confusion that I clearly agreed with Clucky last Haul and so there should not have been an agreement…?

[Juniper] You agreed with Clucky, and Clucky was already agreeing with JonathanDark.

ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Punt this haul.

Let’s get a little more to go around.

punting just loses stuff. I’ll agree with JonathanDark

Doesn’t seem to compelling but I won’t stand in the way.  I agree with JonathanDark

I think that’s Thief Quorum (it’s down to 4 after lendunistus went idle).

I am changing my proposal.  I propose

JonathanDark gets the Unappraised Gem, 4st gets the Cloak and 1 Florins, and Clucky, Desertfrog, JonathanDark, and NadNavillus gets 3 Florins.

Actually, I wanted to punt this in the first place…. I propose we punt this haul.

Wait, why are you wanting to punt this haul? I understand that’s what you wanted to do in the first place, but why?

Well, my initial thought was to punt on this one, then went along with the crowd.  That was before the black market shenanigans. If the CvJ went the way of the only fixing forward, I think we should adjust the haul.  Punting help with that.

Or we make adjustments on the next.

Or maybe I should put that into Dynastic language:

“my thieving brothers and sisters, I’m trying to a good thief and take a smaller cut but I find there are side hustles going on leaving me feeling like I’m the bag holder”

So the problem is that we have a Helm, a Cloak and an Unappraised Gem to divvy out. I’m happy to take your un-punted suggestion and modify it if you’d like a bigger cut so you can invest in side-hustles, but I’m not yet ready to punt on this.

I propose that JonathanDark gets the Unappraised Gem, 4st gets the Cloak and 1 Florins, Juniper gets the Helm, and Clucky, Desertfrog, JonathanDark, and NadNavillus gets 3 Florins.

@NadNavillus, if that is unacceptable, tell me what needs to be adjusted to make it fair. Punting just puts off the decision until the next Haul, and we lose Florins from punting (don’t forget that!), so punting just makes things worse.

Now that Desertfrog has idled out, let me re-propose:

I propose that JonathanDark gets the Unappraised Gem, 4st gets the Cloak and 1 Florins, Juniper gets the Helm, and Clucky, JonathanDark, and NadNavillus get 4 Florins.