Haul distributed, Clucky, NadNavillus, 4st, Desertfrog and JonathanDark are agreed.
Adminned at 03 May 2024 18:47:35 UTC
In a small chest lifted from an open cart at an opportune moment, the thieves find 22 Florins, a Gold Ring and an Unappraised Gem.
All Thieves adopted a Standard Plan for the job, except for Josh who chose Cash and Clucky who chose Stuff.
I’m thinking that both Josh and Clucked funded this heist and will want a bigger cut. I will defer to them to see how they want to cut this but will offer this proposal at equity:
Unappraised Gem goest to Clucky. Gold Ring goes to Josh. 4st, Deserfrong, JonathanDark, Juniper, Xebec and Nadavaillus all get 3 Florins. And Lendunistus gets the extra 4 Florins.
Sorry not “Clucked” but Clucky…..
I’m thinking that both Josh and Clucky funded this heist and will want a bigger cut. I will defer to them to see how they want to cut this but will offer this proposal at equity:
Unappraised Gem goest to Clucky. Gold Ring goes to Josh. 4st, Deserfrong, JonathanDark, Juniper, Xebec and Nadavaillus all get 3 Florins. And Lendunistus gets the extra 4 Florins.
Why should just get the ring (which is worth seven) after only contributing two but I get the gem (which is only worth 5.5) after contributing 3?
I propose that the Unappraised Gem goes to Josh. Gold Ring goes to Clucky. 4st, Deserfrong, JonathanDark, Juniper, Xebec and Nadavaillus all get 3 Florins. And Lendunistus gets the extra 4 Florins.
actually scratch that
I propose that the Unappraised Gem and one Florin goes to Josh. Gold Ring goes to Clucky. 4st, Deserfrong, JonathanDark, Juniper, Xebec, Lendunistus and Nadavaillus all get 3 Florins.
I trust that everyone has noticed the open co-operation between Desertfrog and Clucky?
If you don’t want to get left behind, 4st, JonathanDark and Nadnavillus, I’d suggest that you all cabal up.
You just switched from one proposition to another despite there being no difference in benefit profile to you at all; in fact the only difference is that Clucky gets more and I get less. An odd switch, considering that Clucky is currently well ahead of me; how would you explain that other than as the result of open cooperation?
I just thought Clucky’s argument made sense; and I have no idea who is actually leading because I’m too lazy to go back to calculate Pouch values
Okay now that I checked them it looks like you’re right, so
I agree with NadNavillus (again)
lol why are you letting Josh bully you into simply giving himself a better deal with no change to the deal you’re getting?
my proposal gives Josh a expected result of 6.5 for spending 2, and me an expected result of 7 for spending 3
way fairer than giving Josh an expected result of 7 for spending 2 and me an expected result of 5.5 for spending 3
also its Josh’s own fault he has less florins than others. We shouldn’t be rewarding poor play
@Josh: who I Cabal with is my business, but if you have a better offer in mind, by all means please do offer it. I can be bribed.
@JonathanDark I’m only offering self interest. Clucky is playing hard, he’s already successfully knocked me out the running. I’d advise letting him get too far ahead
Actually, I’ll just propose to give everything to me (a deliberately stupid proposition) and let others figure out this Josh-Clucky dilemma
Let’s start over.
I propose the following: Gold Ring goes to Clucky. Unappraised Gem and 2 Florins goes to Xebec. 4st, Desertfrog, JonathanDark, and Nadavaillus each get 3 Florins. Juniper.ohyegods and lendunistus each get 4 Florins.
Nah, that will kill that game. I propose this haul is busted.
Clucky takes a modest loss on his investment: 2 Florins
lendunistus: gets the Golden ring.
juniper gets the Unappraised Gem.
Everyone else gets 4 Florins: 4st, Desertfrog, JonathanDark, Nadnavillus, Xebec
All florins go to Desertfrog, lendunistus gets gold ring, juniper gets unappraised gem
@juniper sure that works too but I’m still team feed the frog for now because its still the funniest result. But willing to switch tomorrow morning if needed
I proposed the haul was busted.
I “punished” you for getting behind and promoting this lopsided cut, very simple reason. And I’m not sure how offering you more florins from the proposal you’re backing can be seen as punishment.
You’re actually getting more in my proposal and so is everyone else but DesertFrog.
Well, if Desertfrog isn’t in on the joke, then neither am I.
I agree with NadNavillus.
My new proposal:
Clucky gets 2 Florins
lendunistus: gets the Golden ring and 1 Florin
juniper gets the Unappraised Gem and 1 Florin
Desertfrog gets 5 Florins
JonathanDark gets 5 Florins
4st gets 5 Florins
Xebec gets 5 Florins
NadNavillus gets nothing
guess I gotta go with:
Clucky gets 2 Florins
lendunistus: gets the Golden ring
juniper gets the Unappraised Gem
Desertfrog gets 5 Florins
JonathanDark gets 5 Florins
4st gets 5 Florins
Xebec gets 5 Florins
Clucky successfully buys my vote.
I agree with Clucky.
PS: I’m not looking for fairness in every proposition. At some point, someone needs to achieve victory, so bribes are always welcome to me.
Well then lets go all in:
Clucky gets 0 Florins
Nadnavillus gets 0 Florins
lendunistus: gets the Golden ring
juniper gets the Unappraised Gem
Desertfrog gets 6 Florins
JonathanDark gets 6 Florins
4st gets 5 Florins
Xebec gets 5 Florins
Clucky gets 1 Florin
Nadnavillus gets 0 Florins
lendunistus: gets the Golden ring and a Florin
juniper gets the Unappraised Gem and a Florin
Desertfrog gets 7 Florins
JonathanDark gets 0 Florins
4st gets 6 Florins
Xebec gets 6 Florins
I agree with Desertfrog.
FEED THE FROG.
(c’mon lighten up it’s just a game!)
I propose the following:
give Juniper gets the gem
Clucky gets the ring
Xebec gets 2 florins
Frog, Nad, 4st, JonathanDark and Lendun all get 4 florins each
(see my comment in the discord. I believe this makes is to, assuming gems are wroth 5.5, on average for all hauls so far, accounting also for what we’ve put in
Juniper will be at 1.5 over the baseline average
4st and nad will be 1 over
Xebec will be 0.5 over
everyone else will be even
BlogNomic is an online Nomic: a self-modifying game where changing the rules is part of the game. Players make blog posts proposing additions or alterations to the ruleset, discussing and casting votes in the comments: if enough vote in favour, the rules are changed and play continues.
The game has been running since 2003 and resets every month or so. Have a look around the wiki for more information and history. New players are always welcome and can join in the game at any time.
BlogNomic is powered by pMachine ExpressionEngine.
Juniper.ohyegods: she/her
I propose that 2 Florins go to Xebec, 5 to NadNavillus, 2 to ledlunistus, 4 to Josh, 5 to JonathanDark, and 4 to 4st (bringing everybody to 10 unpouched florins except Josh), the Unappraised Gem goes to Xebec, and the Gold Ring goes to Juniper.ohyegods.