My proposition is that Xebec gets the candlestick, 3 Florins each are given to 4st, Clucky, JonathanDark, Josh, Juniper.ohyegods, lendunistus and Nadnavillus, and 2 Florins are given to Desertfrog.

I obviously disagree, instead proposing that Xebec gets the candlestick and one Florin, 3 Florins each are given to Clucky, JonathanDark, Josh, Juniper.ohyegods, lendunistus, and Desertfrog, and 4 Florins are given to 4st

Somehow, you losing one floring in the cut caused you to cut me completely out.  Interesting.  As you said, I obviously disagree.

I’ll jump in with:

Xebec gets the candlestick, 3 Florins each are given to 4st, Clucky, JonathanDark, Josh, Juniper.ohyegods, lendunistus and Nadnavillus, and 2 Florins are given to Desertfrog.

I made an investment of 2 Florins into this Burglary to get more Florins for everyone, which in this case was 6 extra Florins (see the Dice Roller for details). You’re welcome. As such, I feel I should get extra compensation for my investment.

I propose that 4st, Clucky, Desertfrog, Josh, and NadNavillus get 3 Florins each, JonathanDark, Juniper.ohyegods, lendunistus, and Xebec get 2 Florins each, and JonathanDark gets the Candlestick.

I can get behind JonathanDarks investment:

I propose that 4st, Clucky, Desertfrog, Josh, and NadNavillus get 3 Florins each, JonathanDark, Juniper.ohyegods, lendunistus, and Xebec get 2 Florins each, and JonathanDark gets the Candlestick.

Sure

I propose that 4st, Clucky, Desertfrog, Josh, and NadNavillus get 3 Florins each, JonathanDark, Juniper.ohyegods, lendunistus, and Xebec get 2 Florins each, and JonathanDark gets the Candlestick.

I agree with JonathanDark.

I also agree

(with jonathandark)

I agree with JonathanDark.

@NadNavillus: my reasoning was just that as I had to cut someone out, I could as well pick the only one who currently has more Florins/Possessions

It looks like more than a quorum of Thieves agree. It’s been a pleasure doing business with you all.