Somebody did propose that villagers should automatically die when they go idle, but it was shot down. This does still need fixing.

Perhaps unidlers should return to the game in an equivalent of the gaol (perhaps a neighbouring village), and have to make a proposal to return to Zahndorf proper?

If it’s a problem, we could always make a Town Meeting to lynch Clucky “on sight” next time he unidles.

Alternatively, put in a rule that states that when anytime a villager unidles, any and all information about them is re-initialized, meaning clucky coming back could be a werewolf or a villager…though I’m not sure if that completely fixes the issue.

No, that’s abusable - people could keep idling in and out until they got the status they wanted. And there’s still the issue of people idling out to avoid being killed (either to sidestep a lynching, or just to stay safe at night).

Some living Villager should post a town meeting: if Clucky unidles before the end of the Dynasty, kill him immediately.

create a new rule, Clucky is dead.  It’s just in the rules.

The funny thing is, everyone assumed I was a werewolf. I could easily have been an innocent, using this to trap werewolves into revealing their true nature to me—then unidling and making a town meeting to lynch them all in a large bout of awesomness. But I guess all the werewolves were too smart for that. So I might as well just remain idle and forget about this all. (I is still a wolf though ...)

Huh?  What makes you think we assumed you are/were a werewolf?

Obviously if you thought I wasn’t a werewolf, you would not have tried to kill me.

Honestly what I should’ve done was come out with like “Icarus contacted me. I was tricking Icarus. Kill Icarus. Lolz”. And then Icarus would have died, and by that point I would be idled and gone =P

The Persona Non Grata is only an “effectively dead” list - if you wanted to come back and carry on playing, you could just make a proposal to be moved off the list, once you were back.