Hmm… the difficulty scale feels all over the place here. Some of these are incredibly easy, others probably won’t happen at all in this entire dynasty. It’s making it a bit hard to judge whether 3 is the right amount.

Some people already hit fireproof. Expert forager too I think. And elite sniper is super easy to get a friend to help you with. So I think this could cause things to easily end in a round or two

@Clucky, note the wording:

for each Wizard who met the criteria for that Achievement during this Duel

Meaning that the trigger for that achievement had to occur during the Duel in question. Past Duels don’t count.

All that said, if people like the idea of Achievements but just have problems with the specific ones listed, I could re-propose the structure and simply leave the list of possible Achievements blank for now.

It would be helpful if people were to pick out the reasonable ones from what I’ve already proposed. I could also add in a “if after” date so that we don’t even start counting Achievements until after a certain date, so that there’s plenty of time to come up with Achievements collaboratively and tweak them to be roughly balanced.

Hrm… I still worry a lot of these are easy for people to work together on but I’ll switch to

  per Clucky’s worries.

Not against the idea, necessarily, just against how easy some are and how hard others are. Also, I think Clucky’s point with fireproof is that it happened accidentally, and would probably just be incredibly easy to get intentionally. At that point, we may as well just remove fireproof from the list and lower the requirement to 2 achievements, because if people can accidentally get it before achievements even exist, everyone is likely to get it.

Withdrawn, but I’ll re-propose with no Achievements actually defined and a “not until” date, to give us time to work it out.