366 squares is quite the punishment for one bad dice roll, and 1 extra square for being sent to Spirit Island is a pittance in comparison

I can see this working if we add some way to earn a way to prevent or mitigate that happening. (There’s one already — keep a token in Forbidden Island and, if you get sent back, try to use turquoise squares in The Island of Kittens to get back and make another attempt. But it isn’t very reliable and there isn’t so much you can do to try to arrange for that to happen, so we’d want to add more if this proposal passes.) I agree with Habanero, though, that this wouldn’t work on its own, so we’d need to pair it with other Forbidden Island mechanics to make it function well.

I agree with Habanero’s sentiment