Note: this is not an illegal preposal, because the last preposal is actually not a preposal.

Note: the first sentence of this is unclear—how does one alter or repeal on Objection? How does one determine the age of a rule—the day it was created in the Ruleset, or proposed, or last edited? Does the Historian get one or two extra Maps per week? The Historian “is decided”—by whom? During what time period should the number of “new Apocryphal rules that they have mapped” be counted?

In addition to the clarifications, this potentially gives one Scribe a double vote on altering the Core Rules, which I am strongly against.

Note: The number of rules is the number of rules TOTAL since the beginning.

Note:Wait, never mind

Note: Information about who mapped to what rule is secret.  Also, the Historian’s extra Map slot gives them an unfair advantage w.r.t. keeping their office.

Note: fixed. Also, that is why the editor chooses them.

Note: Ties broken randomly?

Note:Yes, thanks

Note: I am surprised no one has voted by now.

Also, right now, it looks like I posted this in the future. Wth?

Time zones.

Also, I just, don’t like this mechanic. The nature of the dynasty is one such that older rules should be tweaked with relatively often, to play nice with newer rules, as well as vice versa.

Same as raichu honestly. And yeah, no one voteing seems to be a theme of this dynasty. It sucks having to wait for everything to time out all the time.

I’ve been kind of low activity at all, lately; I’m going to try to bounce back. As for the lack of votes, I think the Notes: are partly to blame? Definitely, in this case.

There are also times I’ve avoided being the first to vote just in case I feel there might be a hole in a Proposal, and don’t want to block a possible spot-and-fix with an early vote. Which, is a habit I should try to break.

I do have to say, no one here has a problem with the cellermaster.

And the Cellarmaster doesn’t have anything to do with affecting old rules or voting? Unless I missed something.

True

I was…. Nevermind

per RaichuKFM.  I would support a version that got an extra vote on proposals that only modify Provisional rules.

Valiant effort.