Thursday, July 09, 2020

Proposal: How about this [Victory]

Timed out 4 votes to 5 with one DEF. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 11 Jul 2020 19:11:12 UTC

(I unidle.)

Add a new rule titled “Victory”:

Any Gambler with 2 Plaques has achieved victory.

The rule “The Switch” may not be repealed by an Ascension Address. (However, dynastic terms in it are changed, and this rule may be repealed by Ascension Address.)

Alright, I guess it wasn’t me keeping the game stale. I could run a dynasty here. We could have fun. We don’t need to switch from a Metadynasty.

Comments

pokes:

09-07-2020 19:08:17 UTC

I’m planning on editing this with some way to give consideration to the Switch rule.

pokes:

09-07-2020 19:14:33 UTC

Edited.

derrick: he/him

09-07-2020 19:43:04 UTC

for

Raven1207: he/him

09-07-2020 20:18:45 UTC

for

Publius Scribonius Scholasticus: he/they

09-07-2020 20:40:53 UTC

for

Darknight: he/him

10-07-2020 00:22:47 UTC

imperial

Zyborg:

10-07-2020 01:38:52 UTC

against I know that this will likely pass anyways, but I’m against any rule being enacted specifically to instantly make someone a winner. Although it probably is wrapping up anyways. So I’m basically voting on principle.

Josh: he/him

10-07-2020 07:54:09 UTC

imperial Better than nothing, seeing as how the switch dynasty seems unwilling to wrap up.

Kevan: Oracle he/him

10-07-2020 09:27:07 UTC

[Josh] That seems fair when we don’t know when the Wordpress site will be ready to go live. And there’s the ongoing thing that nobody can explain whether Wordpress players are playing to win their game (and maybe kill this dynasty in the process), or are just testing stuff.

against This game certainly needs an Emperor, but yes, a straight “I win” proposal is unsatisfying, and I don’t want to endorse a strategy of (in Pokes’ own words) “trying to keep my lead by keeping the game stale”. If we’re ending the game on fool’s gold, Jumble and I potentially have 2 Winner Medallions each, to Pokes’ zero.

Make it “3 plaques or 3 medallions” and I’d take it.

Jumble:

10-07-2020 16:25:37 UTC

against Per Kevan

Tantusar: he/they

11-07-2020 04:10:12 UTC

against look if you’re stealing the win, just put that in the rules

pokes:

11-07-2020 09:45:25 UTC

@Tantusar: Is it “stealing”? Or more like “walking into a shop in broad daylight, and asking”?

“3 plaques or 3 medallions” is a loss for me, since plaques are now unavailable. More generally, any victory condition weighting plaques together with medallions becomes a negotiation between me and Jumble. What if we flipped for it, at the final table?

Darknight: he/him

11-07-2020 13:12:51 UTC

against cov