Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Call for Judgment: Idle Gnomes cannot vote

Failed by Ascension Address- Darknight

Adminned at 14 Jan 2009 21:50:37 UTC

Bucky has vetoed some proposals within BLO. However, in order to VOTE, one needs to be unidle. Becaise Bucky is Idle within BLO, he cannot vote.

Therefore, enact Proposal “[BLO] Ok, I’ll make it legal and stylish this time”, which should have normally passed because it reached BLO Quorum.

Comments

Yoda:

01-13-2009 19:41:43 UTC

against The BLO and GNO Faction Rulesets each contain a rule which states that the Supreme Being can vote on or veto BLO proposals.

arthexis:

01-13-2009 19:46:36 UTC

for Supreme Being is not defined on BLO.

Bucky:

01-13-2009 19:58:34 UTC

against .

Compare to the diplomacy rule for MIC.

arthexis:

01-13-2009 20:05:50 UTC

That one says “MIC Chairman” specifically. The Oath of Fealty doesn’t specify.

Bucky:

01-13-2009 20:17:52 UTC

However, it implies extremely strongly.

Klisz:

01-13-2009 20:37:55 UTC

against

Klisz:

01-13-2009 20:44:47 UTC

Also, I hereby CoV on that proposal to AGAINST, thus preventing it from reaching quorum.

Qwazukee:

01-13-2009 21:40:15 UTC

imperial  Not going to figure it out now.

Amnistar:

01-13-2009 22:13:22 UTC

against

Klisz:

01-13-2009 22:23:54 UTC

One more thing: the Supreme Being veto is not counted as a vote. The rulesets simply state that the Being may veto proposals, not that e may vote VETO.

Darknight:

01-13-2009 22:47:37 UTC

against

Qwazukee:

01-13-2009 23:00:54 UTC

against party line

arthexis:

01-14-2009 04:05:44 UTC

against  CoV per the will of the mayority

Yoda:

01-14-2009 17:18:21 UTC

Need 1 more for quorum.