Saturday, November 06, 2010

Proposal: If you can’t join ‘em, beat ‘em!

Fails 1-12: cannot be enacted without CoV. -Bucky

Adminned at 07 Nov 2010 11:20:48 UTC

If Proposal: Spelling Lessons fails, then this does nothing.

Add a new rule: Possession is 9/10 of the Law

Once a week Students with the condition “Ghost” may replace a “Study” action during a Lesson with a “Possession” action. This action targets a Student with the “Alive” condition. Instead of increasing their grade by an increment of one, the Possessing student increases their grade by an increment of two, so long as their new grade does not equal or exceed the grade (at the time the Possession action is taken) of the target of Possession. As per the “Lessons” rule, Students must post a comment to the appropriate Lesson’s entry describing their behavior and which must include a designation of the target of the “Possession” action.

Add a new rule: Headshot!

Once a week Students with the condition Alive may replace a “Disrupt” action during a Lesson with a “Disorient” action. This action has all of the effects of a “Disrupt” action with the added effect of decrementing a targeted Student, whose condition is either “Ghost” or “Zombie” by two steps instead of one. As per the “Lessons” rule, Students must post a comment to the appropriate Lesson’s entry describing their behavior and which must include a designation of the target of the “Disorient” action.

Add a new rule; Mmmrrrrghhhh…

During a Lesson, no Student with the “Zombie” condition, hereafter “Zombie Student,” may have their grade in that subject lowered below the lowest grade held by a Zombie Student attending the the same Lesson. At least three Zombie Students must be attending a Lesson for this protection to take effect. If a Zombie Student has his or her grade reduced by a “Disorient” action then that reduction may take him or her no lower than one step below the the lowest grade held by a Zombie Student attending the same lesson.

There’s an advantage to pretty much everything as long as you can find it. Those students of the less than corporeal persuasion can bring the concept of “Study Partners” to a whole new plain of awkwardness. The livelier kids have learned ways to exploit their vitally challenged peers in ways that will gross out everyone else in class. As for the studying dead, well, who needs brains? A horde, after all, is only as smart as its dumbest member.

Comments

Darknight: he/him

06-11-2010 03:29:27 UTC

imperial

Thane Q:

06-11-2010 04:09:32 UTC

against Seems like the Alive and Ghost options are quite a bit stronger than the Zombie option. From my reading, it appears Zombie Students have no tangible benefits from this proposal.

FuzzyLogic:

06-11-2010 05:02:45 UTC

imperial

Tuzgai:

06-11-2010 06:01:00 UTC

imperial

Ambisinister:

06-11-2010 07:22:21 UTC

The intended benefit to Zombie Students is that say you have three zombies taking a lesson in Explosive Latin, and their grades are B, A, and A+, no zombie could have their grade reduced below a B except by the proposed Disorient action.

Josh: Observer he/they

06-11-2010 08:04:52 UTC

against

Klisz:

06-11-2010 14:11:02 UTC

for Your own fault for zombifying yourself, Thane.

Purplebeard:

06-11-2010 14:38:29 UTC

imperial

Kevan: he/him

06-11-2010 15:09:36 UTC

against Not entirely clear whether a “replaced” action is your own, or somebody else’s. (It might be simpler just to list them as actions in the “Lessons” rule, which can only be taken by Ghosts or Zombies.) And “Instead of increasing their grade by an increment of one” seems a bit too vague - does it only apply to that class, or can I use it in other classes and Library study as well?

Roujo: he/him

06-11-2010 15:24:44 UTC

against IMO, a zombie Trifecta would be too powerful compared to the other powers. (Unless Alives organize and Disorient each zombie in turn, which is doable but need impeccable teamwork.)

Thane Q:

06-11-2010 17:22:58 UTC

If just one F-grade Zombie is in class, it will mess up a Zombie team’s benefit up and they’ll have no benefits at all. And if Zombie team alone is there, two of the higher ones get no real benefit if someone disrupts the class.

The only loophole that may benefit Zombies is ability to disrupt without harming grade, but that still requires 2-3 working together, and can be messed up by any other Zombie working against them with a suitably low grade.

Roujo: he/him

06-11-2010 17:52:14 UTC

True, but still. Sorry =P

Brendan: he/him

07-11-2010 14:06:23 UTC

against A bit too controversial, I think.

Klisz:

07-11-2010 16:18:15 UTC

against to speed things along.

Klisz:

07-11-2010 16:20:02 UTC

(Though I’d like to note that being alive should be a better condition to be in than the others, in order to prevent people from suiciding.)

Ujalu, the unnecessary.:

07-11-2010 18:15:29 UTC

against

Bucky:

07-11-2010 19:19:22 UTC

against