Wednesday, May 17, 2023

Proposal: Includo

Fails to be popular 4-0, lacking Quorum after more than 48 hours. -Bucky

Adminned at 20 May 2023 16:08:09 UTC

In the rule Resolution of Proposals, change “It has been Vetoed or Withdrawn” to “It has been Vetoed and/or Withdrawn”.

Clarifying that this is an inclusive or rather than an exclusive one, to forestall the possible argument that a proposal that has been both vetoed and withdrawn is actually not unpopular.

Comments

Bucky:

17-05-2023 22:14:56 UTC

for

JonathanDark: Sovereign he/him

17-05-2023 22:41:32 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

18-05-2023 07:54:08 UTC

Why this one in particular? The core rules have a couple of hundred “or"s in there, including big ones like “may submit a Proposal to change the Ruleset or Gamestate”, and CfJs only being allowed if there is disagreement or urgency.

Josh: he/they

18-05-2023 08:23:25 UTC

@Kevan Because it’s the only one that was on my radar! I think enshrining an exclusive or needs a lot of thought, and this doesn’t

Josh: he/they

18-05-2023 08:39:09 UTC

Need a lot of thought, that is

I think you know my proposal style well enough by now to appreciate that sometimes a very narrow scope is better. Look, even Bucky voted for, that never happens.

redtara: they/them

18-05-2023 15:58:45 UTC

for

summai:

20-05-2023 04:45:33 UTC

Would the fact that this particular or is explicitly stated to be inclusive make it a reasonable interpretation that the others are exclusive?