Monday, October 12, 2015

Call for Judgment: Invidia Clarification

6 votes against. That’s a quorum. Failed by Elias IX.

Adminned at 14 Oct 2015 02:45:03 UTC

In the Rule Vices, add the following text to the end of the section that corresponds to Invidia:-

Upon choosing Superbia, the Cardinal gains one Benefice. Upon choosing Luxuria, the Cardinal gains one Nepotism.

Reset all Vices of all Cardinals to the default value for that stat. Remove 1 Benefice from ayesdeeef.

CfJing as I am out of Proposal slots.

Resetting the contentious values with a better clarified Ruleset and starting over. Finding middle ground on the previous CfJ’s intended effect. Everybody happy?

Comments

Brendan:

10-12-2015 18:50:38 UTC

against This makes Invidia both a stat grind and easily the most powerful Vice.

Kevan:

10-12-2015 19:08:42 UTC

This doesn’t seem any clearer. Which Cardinal is “the Cardinal”?

against

ayesdeeef:

10-12-2015 21:03:55 UTC

@ Brendan: Invidia is still the weakest Vice. The only reason it has seemed so powerful thus far is because no-one has set their own Vice, which is exactly what Invidia is intended to encourage them to do.

@ Kevan: It makes sense in the context of the Ruleset.

Kevan:

10-12-2015 21:21:35 UTC

It really doesn’t:

“A Cardinal may not choose Invidia as their Vice if they have any Benefices. As a Daily Action, a Cardinal whose Vice is Invidia may target a Cardinal who does not currently have a Vice, and set that Cardinal’s Vice to any of the options in this list. They may not use this action to set a Vice that the targeted Cardinal would not normally be able to choose. Upon choosing Superbia, the Cardinal gains one Benefice. Upon choosing Luxuria, the Cardinal gains one Nepotism.

Is “the Cardinal” the targetted Cardinal or the Cardinal taking the action?

Thrawn:

10-13-2015 05:10:42 UTC

against

Purplebeard:

10-13-2015 14:03:00 UTC

against

ayesdeeef:

10-13-2015 15:14:38 UTC

against s/k to speed things up

Kevan:

10-13-2015 15:47:35 UTC

You can’t self-kill a Call for Judgment.

Elias IX:

10-14-2015 02:37:10 UTC

against