Friday, October 10, 2014

Call for Judgment: It depends on what the meaning of the word “when” is.

Times out and fails 0-4. -Bucky

Adminned at 14 Oct 2014 14:09:49 UTC

(As of the time this CfJ was posted:)

  • Eritivus is not currently Assisting.
  • Eritivus did not make a Play as an Assisting Player on the most recent Shooting post.

 

Comments

Eritivus:

10-10-2014 05:56:06 UTC

against

As you can see in the GNDT, when I kicked to Sylphrena, I went to “-” before going to “:”.

This is because I didn’t realize that I could make a third Play until very shortly after (I’m guessing within 5min, but not sure given the timestamp granularity on the GNDT) I started the kick.

I think it was legal for me to go Assisting, since a span of multiple GNDT actions can constitute a single atomic update to the Gamestate. However, I can see an interpretation where “when transferring its ownership” means I missed my chance to go Assisting.

ayesdeeef:

10-10-2014 14:15:11 UTC

against I think it’s fine for you to go assisting but I’m so rattled by all of this that I’m not sure.

Bucky:

10-11-2014 17:02:32 UTC

against

Sylphrena:

10-12-2014 01:33:30 UTC

against