Monday, January 08, 2024

Proposal: It Was A Graveyard Smash

Timed out, 2-4. Failed by JonathanDark.

Adminned at 10 Jan 2024 06:26:36 UTC

If the proposal here https://blognomic.com/archive/echos_of_the_past does not pass, this proposal does nothing

Give Shamblers the following Deathrattle

First, calculate each Necromancer’s Shambler Score by counting the total number of other Necromancers they are stronger than

Then, given all Necromancers with the highest Shambler Score 3 Legacy

If only one Necromancer was awarded Legacy by that step, give all Necromancers with the second highest Shambler Score 2 Legacy

If, after both of these steps, only 2 Necromancers were awarded Legacy by this process, give all Necromancers with the third highest Shambler Score 1 Legacy

Comments

Vovix: he/him

08-01-2024 20:11:50 UTC

for

Zack: he/him

08-01-2024 20:58:19 UTC

for

Desertfrog:

09-01-2024 09:09:03 UTC

for

Josh: he/they

09-01-2024 09:46:33 UTC

against This is just Points for Desertfrog, as no-one else has time to catch up to them before the rule expires.

naught:

09-01-2024 15:41:44 UTC

Only 1 point more than the rest of us, as currently we are all tied for 2nd. Besides, I doubt Legacy points will actually be directly used for a victory condition. At least, I don’t plan on making such a rule.

for

Josh: he/they

09-01-2024 16:13:41 UTC

@naught We don’t *have* to vote for anybody to have more points than us, no matter how few or how useable they are! What is the positive case for this proposal? It’s effectively just “give one player free stuff, everyone else gets nothing”. Why is anyone voting for this?

Desertfrog:

09-01-2024 16:39:36 UTC

CoV against because Clucky can make lots of Shamblers with The Meaning of Life, resulting in 3 legacy for Clucky, 2 for me and only 1 for everyone else

Also, it’s a bit unfair given that Locations are just about to die and some people won’t even get a chance to have Shamblers

naught:

09-01-2024 16:42:12 UTC

Desertfrog makes a good point about the timing and fairness thereof.

CoV against

Clucky: he/him

09-01-2024 16:57:40 UTC

there is still plenty of time for others to go to the library and get a copy of The Meaning of Life. probably can actually get more than me pretty easily, given I also got Necrotic Redirection too and didn’t really need it

I feel like we should have some systems in place for making gameplay in the first part of the dynasty meaningful

Desertfrog:

09-01-2024 17:20:18 UTC

Well, I don’t think two days is really plenty of time, and anyway only two people will get to the library because there are only two corpses there

Zack: he/him

09-01-2024 18:29:44 UTC

against