Thursday, December 18, 2008

Proposal: Kill Smith!

vetoed—Yoda

Adminned at 17 Dec 2008 20:07:00 UTC

Decrease the relationship of every player by 20.

Comments

Rodlen:

18-12-2008 02:28:07 UTC

against No.  Just no.

Klisz:

18-12-2008 02:29:45 UTC

One against vote does not a failed proposal make, Rodlen.

Rodlen:

18-12-2008 02:31:15 UTC

Lets see…history shows this kind of proposal has a high chance of being vetoed.

Klisz:

18-12-2008 02:33:11 UTC

I need to get it to reach quorum before time runs out! COME, MY DARK MASTER, ELJEFE!

Klisz:

18-12-2008 02:33:32 UTC

“Time” here meaning “time until Yoda sees this”.

Amnistar: he/him

18-12-2008 02:49:02 UTC

against

Once again, a gamestate change specifically to ‘pull the rug’ out of someone that is a likely winner seems…silly.

I don’t have anything against conspiring to keep him from winning, just don’t change the rules to make it possible.

eljefe:

18-12-2008 03:04:48 UTC

against

But here’s the problem: You change the rules of Nomic to help yourself win. Usually that victory can be achieved by different means so the proposals make for a more circuitous route to victory.

In a horse race game like this there’s no point in doing that. All proposals are either going to be “Kill Smith!” or “Let Smith Live!” And then those get vetoed.

My Morgue proposal was basically “Kill Smith!”, only I dressed it up a little and added some flavor.

Cayvie:

18-12-2008 03:06:40 UTC

for

im bein contrary

Klisz:

18-12-2008 03:08:17 UTC

You’re voting against a proposal that would help you? You really are Anthony!

Cayvie:

18-12-2008 03:14:32 UTC

no anthony would just make up a couple fake accounts, claim they were family members, and have them agree with him on everything.

eljefe:

18-12-2008 03:24:11 UTC

DC-

Well, it’ll help all of us since it’d be an allied victory for the Team Die Smith (German for “The Smith”).

But it’s still a little on the nose, for my tastes.

I’d rather we vote to create a Death Ray, vote to install it on an alien battleship, so for the aliens to abduct Jason, and THEN vote everyone’s relationship negative.

Zap.

eljefe:

18-12-2008 03:24:33 UTC

Oh, and tell me tales of the good King Anthony.

Darknight: he/him

18-12-2008 03:37:13 UTC

against

arthexis: he/him

18-12-2008 03:43:40 UTC

against Really, I think we can achieve this through other means.

Klisz:

18-12-2008 03:54:49 UTC

against

Yoda:

18-12-2008 04:06:41 UTC

veto Trust me.  You don’t want to do that…