Thursday, October 20, 2011

Call for Judgment: lets have some order

failed by CfJ “http://blognomic.com/archive/compromise_mark_4_again” -Bucky
unfailed by coppro - the enactment was illegal
Times out and refails, 1-18.—Brendan

Adminned at 22 Oct 2011 09:37:21 UTC

Amend the second paragraph of rule 1.7

All Artists may cast Votes on that CfJ to indicate agreement or disagreement with the position taken in that CfJ. Unfailed CfJs continue until they reach a Quorum of FOR Votes, a Quorum of AGAINST Votes, or until 48 hours have passed since they were posted. After this time, if more than half the cast Votes are FOR Votes, the CfJ may be enacted by any Admin by updating or correcting the Gamestate and Ruleset as specified. Otherwise, the CfJ fails. A Failed CfJ has no further effect.

to read

All Artists may cast Votes on that CfJ to indicate agreement or disagreement with the position taken in that CfJ. Unresolved CFfJs cannot be resolved if there is an older unresolved CfJ and unresolved CfJs continue until they reach a Quorum of FOR Votes, a Quorum of AGAINST Votes, or until 48 hours have passed since they were posted. After this time, if more than half the cast Votes are FOR Votes, the CfJ may be enacted by any Admin by updating or correcting the Gamestate and Ruleset as specified. Otherwise, the CfJ fails. A Failed CfJ has no further effect.

Comments

Kevan: he/him

20-10-2011 08:39:25 UTC

against Requiring CfJs to be processed in order would risk slowing them down, which defeats some of the point of having them; if I could see that a CfJ was about to be made that would inconvenience me, I could make a spurious but controversial CfJ that we’d have to address first.

Prince Anduril:

20-10-2011 13:03:13 UTC

against Yep - per Kevan. And also this would prevent people making hijack CfJs in order to undo the damage of an as yet unpassed CfJ.

Bucky:

20-10-2011 18:20:31 UTC

against

Pavitra:

20-10-2011 20:56:26 UTC

against

Amnistar: he/him

20-10-2011 23:32:14 UTC

against following Kevin’s lead.

Klisz:

20-10-2011 23:33:33 UTC

against

redtara: they/them

20-10-2011 23:59:39 UTC

against

Shadowclaw:

21-10-2011 00:06:47 UTC

against

Ornithopter:

21-10-2011 00:47:30 UTC

against

Brendan: he/him

21-10-2011 02:59:52 UTC

against

Wooble:

21-10-2011 11:20:28 UTC

against

Rodney:

21-10-2011 13:41:06 UTC

against

ChronosPhaenon:

21-10-2011 14:46:46 UTC

against

ais523:

21-10-2011 16:38:56 UTC

against

Amnistar: he/him

21-10-2011 21:03:06 UTC

15 against votes.

Doctor29:

21-10-2011 22:34:15 UTC

against 16

southpointingchariot:

22-10-2011 04:46:20 UTC

against

Josh: Observer he/they

22-10-2011 10:29:37 UTC

against