Monday, April 01, 2024

Proposal: Looping the Holes

Reached quorum 4 votes to 0. Enacted by Kevan. Any criteria that do not meet this are now automatically blanked.

Adminned at 02 Apr 2024 08:57:46 UTC

Add the following to “Criteria”

Private criteria may only refer to the contents of the shot, and may not refer to things such as the date, other criteria, or the contents of other documents.

Kevan’s “Satisfies the text of my 54th secret key” approach is a nice trick, but as there is nothing stopping him from changing his 54th secret key it would allow people to easily change their criteria without actually changing their criteria which I think is against the spirit of the dynasty.

Also think we should simply be able to look at the picture and not have to worry about things like what other criteria were at the time or when the shot was posted.


Josh: Observer he/they

01-04-2024 18:29:37 UTC

Personally, I would prefer that some metadata be permitted, although I would support that l the extent of that data being constrained.

Broadly, I don’t see why current Criteria (or those swiftly added over the next five hours) are excluded from the restriction.

I also note that we have no insight as to the criteria that allowed you to gain access to the Composition award; I’m not sure that closing the openly-available loopholes that Kevan and I utilised while leaving your secret ones available is good for the players still on their ways up.

JonathanDark: he/him

01-04-2024 18:33:06 UTC

I would support a “all players must reset all private criteria one time” as part of this Proposal.

Clucky: he/him

01-04-2024 18:40:38 UTC

I’m fine getting rid of the “Private criteria set before April 2nd 2024 do not have to follow this reqiurement” clause, it just didn’t seem fair to potentially force people to change their criteria

The loophole I used is a lot harder to close. But I do agree its reasonable to reveal all past criteria.

JonathanDark: he/him

01-04-2024 23:51:19 UTC


NadNavillus: he/him

02-04-2024 03:25:11 UTC


Kevan: he/him

02-04-2024 08:56:39 UTC