Tuesday, May 02, 2006

Proposal: Make it last

Timed out, 2-7. Failed by Angry Grasshopper.

Adminned at 06 May 2006 15:35:59 UTC

in Rule 1.9, replace:

When a Dynasty has been won, all Monks’ GNDT (http://blognomic.com/gndt/generic.cgi?nomic=blog) stats are reset to zero or blank. Any Monks who were idle throughout that Dynasty may be removed from the game, at Abbot’s discretion.

The Hiatus then continues until the new Abbot posts an Ascension Address to the BlogNomic weblog - this shall specify Abbot’s chosen theme for the new round, and may optionally include a proclamation that any number of Rules will be repealed, and/or that the words “Monk” and “Abbot” will be replaced with new theme-appropriate terms. If the new Abbot chooses not to repeal a rule, e may also replace any keyword in those rules with a new theme-appropriate term. The remaining rules, after the new Abbot’s proclamation, shall be renumbered to keep a sequential progression. The new Abbot may also proclaim at the Ascension Address the veto of any Pending Proposals.

with:

The Hiatus then continues until the new Abbot posts an Ascension Address to the BlogNomic weblog - this shall specify Abbot’s chosen theme for the new round, and may optionally include a proclamation that any number of Rules will be repealed, and/or that the words “Monk” and “Abbot” will be replaced with new theme-appropriate terms.  If the new Abbot chooses not to repeal a rule, e may also replace any keyword in those rules with a new theme-appropriate term. The remaining rules, after the new Abbot’s proclamation, shall be renumbered to keep a sequential progression. When a Dynasty has been won, the Abbot decides which GNDT(http://blognomic.com/gndt/generic.cgi?nomic=blog) stats (which are mandated by the remaining Rules) should be kept and resets the remaining stats to zero or blank.  The new Abbot may also proclaim at the Ascension Address the veto of any Pending Proposals.

If more than half of all comments containing counted votes also contain the text “Blessings are Forever”,  add the sentence “If this Rule is not repealed at the end of this Dynasty, then Blessings are not reset with the rest of the GNDT stats.” to the end of Rule 2.1.

Comments

Bucky:

02-05-2006 22:05:48 UTC

for  because Blessings are Forever!

TAE:

02-05-2006 22:41:15 UTC

against
grrrr grrrr grrrr

Elias IX:

02-05-2006 23:24:18 UTC

Was this a subject of past discussion before the Switch? That I do not know.

imperial

Bucky:

02-05-2006 23:54:30 UTC

Well, AG decided everyone could keep their Blessings at the beginning of this Dynasty.  I’m just formalizing the power which is apparently already there.

Hix:

03-05-2006 14:10:18 UTC

imperial

Purplebeard:

03-05-2006 15:38:16 UTC

for no Blessings are forever! /me grins

Thelonious:

03-05-2006 15:58:24 UTC

against

I think a clean slate is a good idea, otherwise newcomers are put at a real disadvantage and may be put off from joining.  However, if this passes, I suppose Blessings are Forever.

“For, behold, I create new heavens and a new earth: and the former shall not be remembered, nor come into mind.” (Isaiah 65:17)

(I’m particuarly pleased with my verse for this one.)

Hix:

03-05-2006 16:46:27 UTC

imperial no Blessings are Forever.  And shame on you for suggesting Blessings for yourself!

Rodney:

05-05-2006 15:07:23 UTC

against

Bucky:

05-05-2006 21:45:18 UTC

AG, your vote decides this.

Angry Grasshopper:

06-05-2006 22:34:24 UTC

against