Monday, October 24, 2011

Proposal: Making CfJs Fair Play

SK—arthexis

Adminned at 25 Oct 2011 20:10:39 UTC

In rule 1.9 Fair Play, change the sentence:

If any of these rules are found to have been broken, or if an Artist’s behaviour or actions are otherwise deemed unacceptable (socially or otherwise), a proposal or CfJ may be made to reprimand or punish the perpetrator or, in cases of extreme or repeated violations, remove them from the game and bar them from rejoining.

To instead read:

If any of these rules are found to have been broken, or if an Artist’s behaviour or actions are otherwise deemed unacceptable (socially or otherwise), a proposal or CfJ may be made to, if enacted, reprimand or punish the perpetrator or, in cases of extreme or repeated violations, remove them from the game and bar them from rejoining.

Comments

zuff:

24-10-2011 04:37:02 UTC

I don’t get it. What’s the intent of the change? To clarify that the proposal or CfJ only punishes the player if enacted? I think that’s reasonably clear from the current wording, but I don’t have any particular objection to the amendment, if that’s the case.

omd:

24-10-2011 04:41:31 UTC

against

Klisz:

24-10-2011 05:04:49 UTC

imperial

Qwazukee:

24-10-2011 05:50:17 UTC

against dilatory?

scshunt:

24-10-2011 06:41:37 UTC

for

Prince Anduril:

24-10-2011 07:31:19 UTC

zuff is right, this change is superceded by the way CfJs work (if they fail they do nothing). So this change makes no difference, and I prefer the wording of the original.

against

Kevan: he/him

24-10-2011 08:24:26 UTC

against

Shadowclaw:

24-10-2011 10:48:14 UTC

against

ChronosPhaenon:

24-10-2011 12:54:19 UTC

against

southpointingchariot:

24-10-2011 13:10:38 UTC

imperial

Wooble:

24-10-2011 13:41:46 UTC

against

Ely:

24-10-2011 14:20:04 UTC

for

Clucky: he/him

24-10-2011 18:02:31 UTC

against pointless

Ornithopter:

24-10-2011 18:21:23 UTC

against

arthexis: he/him

24-10-2011 18:45:15 UTC

against Self-kill based on unpopular demand

Wakukee:

25-10-2011 00:01:27 UTC

against