Call for Judgment: Manual Ratification
failed by CfJ “http://blognomic.com/archive/compromise_mark_4_again” -Bucky
unfailed by coppro - the enactment was illegal
Times out and refails, 1-16.—Brendan
Adminned at 21 Oct 2011 12:20:23 UTC
It occurs to me that we still might have controversy regarding the state of the game even after several possibly-necessary attempts to make the various viewpoints converge on the legality of making CfJs. I therefore suggest we directly set the gamestate by CfJ to remove any trace of ambiguity.
Change the Ruleset, with the exception of the rule named “Gamestate Tracking”, to match what the Ruleset wiki page contained at revision 14227 (http://blognomic.com/wiki/index.php?title=Ruleset&oldid=14227). Change the Zeitgeist, Fauz Pas, and Syles to match what their corresponding wiki pages contained at the time this CfJ was created.
If the CfJ “Drawing the Line Somewhere” passed, replace “Whenever an Artist posts an entry, that entry is considered a Work of Art.” in rule 2.1 with:
Whenever an Artist posts a blog entry which is not a Proposal, Call for Judgment, Declaration of Victory or Ascension Address, that entry is considered a Work of Art.
Set the GNDT’s columns as follows:
Bucky has 2 acclaim, comex and Kevan have 1 acclaim, everyone else has 0 acclaim. Set everyone’s Movement to whatever its current value is according to the GNDT as long as such a value is legal according to the rule “Movements”, or to no movement otherwise. The Founder of each Movement mentioned in the GNDT log before this CfJ passes is considered to be the first Artist to have had that Movement in their Movement field according to the GNDT log.
Kevan: he/him
Not entirely convinced that we should worry this much about “true” gamestate; for any CfJ that passes or fails, there can be some players who consider the voted interpretation “controversial”, and maybe they were objectively in the right, but we shouldn’t cater to cleaning up a rejected gamestate. Or if we should, it should be something that the ruleset does automatically whenever a CfJ passes.