Wednesday, February 22, 2017

Call for Judgment: Mistaken eating of redcap!

Reached a quorum of against votes, 0-5. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 22 Feb 2017 22:58:53 UTC

Change Derrick’s inventory to “red cap”

Change the action of combining and consuming red cap and silver bark to just eating silver bark.

I did not intend to eat the redcap with the silver bark.

I realized I didn’t want to part way through an atomic action. I had to complete, and wasn’t sure if I was obligated to complete the action or if I could undo everything part way through. Sorry. Please have mercy.

Comments

Kevan: he/him

22-02-2017 14:49:05 UTC

Combining remedies isn’t an Atomic Action, it’s just “A villager can choose to combine any number of the remedies they carry directly before using them by announcing those two actions in the same blogpost.” If someone announces it in a blog post (which you have), then it’s happened. A CfJ asking to take back any mistaken action would be fair enough, though.

Fortunately the whole thing looks like it might have been illegal anyway, according to the GNDT log:

22/02 03:45 (UTC) - derrick
  Comment:
((Foraging for Mandrake, Nightshade, Red Cap, Silver Bark or Wolfsbane DICE5:3 ))

22/02 03:47 (UTC) - derrick
  derrick’s Remedies = Mandrake, Nightshade, Red Cap (was mandrake, nightshade)
(results of foraging)

22/02 14:24 (UTC) - derrick
  Comment:
(Foraging for Mandrake, Nightshade, Red Cap, Silver Bark or Wolfsbane DICE5:1 )

22/02 14:24 (UTC) - derrick
  derrick’s Remedies = Mandrake, Mandrake, Red Cap (was Mandrake, Nightshade, Red Cap)
((dropping nightshade, adding mandrake foraged for))

I can’t see that there’s any way to “drop” an unwanted Remedy, and per the UTC game clock you’ve foraged twice in the same day here.

against

Viv:

22-02-2017 14:52:20 UTC

*cough* should be possible to make it all a fever dream, not sure if you’d wake in the forest or the market (but with Mandrake,  Nightshade,  Red Cap).
against

Kevan: he/him

22-02-2017 14:56:21 UTC

Moving to the Market was a separate and legal action. Swapping two Mandrakes for a Silver Bark wasn’t legal, because Derrick didn’t have two Mandrakes at that point, and dropping the Nightshade wasn’t either, because I don’t think you can drop Remedies.

My reading is that Derrick should now be in the Market carrying Mandrake, Nightshade and Red Cap.

Viv:

22-02-2017 14:59:36 UTC

Agreed. Market.

derrick: he/him

22-02-2017 16:46:36 UTC

Just looked at the definitions, and we do indeed start and end days on UTC time. That’s dumb. I certainly did not intend to break that rule. Good to know though. Thursday will start at 6:00 PM my time.

 

Kevan: he/him

22-02-2017 17:04:52 UTC

Swings and roundabouts. I’ve updated your GNDT to “Mandrake, Nightshade and Red Cap”, if you’re not contesting the call.

derrick: he/him

22-02-2017 17:12:55 UTC

Is it also possible to have my location back to the forest? without the double Mandrake there is no reason to to move to the market. Or is that a separate Call for judgement?

Kevan: he/him

22-02-2017 17:20:38 UTC

That would have to be a separate CfJ, as this one is explicitly just changing your inventory and your consumption action.

derrick: he/him

22-02-2017 18:48:29 UTC

against

Self kill.

Kevan: he/him

22-02-2017 19:09:43 UTC

CfJs can’t actually be self-killed, but your vote does move it towards failing.

Madrid:

22-02-2017 19:37:02 UTC

against ASSISTING THE SELF EUTHANASIA

pokes:

22-02-2017 21:44:53 UTC

against