Monday, February 05, 2018

Proposal: Mourge

Reached quorum 5 votes to 0. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 07 Feb 2018 19:04:48 UTC

Make a Rule titled “Swifter Than The Admins” with the text

A Dead proposal is a self-killed proposal where all of the proposals in the queue at or above it are either 48 or more hours old or self-killed or vetoed. For the purposes of the “Proposals” rule, but not its subrules, Dead proposals are not considered pending.

This should be better right? The only time it allows for the “disposable” proposals like Self-Failed had is if the queue consists of self-killed proposals.

posted by card at 05 Feb 2018 20:12:00 UTC Comments (7)

Comments

Madrid:

05-02-2018 20:31:30 UTC

Shrug, works for me.

Kevan: he/him

05-02-2018 20:44:17 UTC

for Seems a bit niche but let’s see what happens.

Madrid:

05-02-2018 20:47:11 UTC

for

Diabecko:

05-02-2018 21:18:40 UTC

for

PineTreeQ:

05-02-2018 22:10:30 UTC

for

Madrid:

06-02-2018 00:57:29 UTC

A think a way to eliminate Admin advantage entirely would be to be able to deputy-Admin somehow mechanically or have Admin membership be a lot more liberal.

Diabecko:

06-02-2018 15:00:42 UTC

Ideally Admin status shouldn’t be a gameplay advantage and transforming it into some form of game mechanic available to all players might encourage unfair use of the status. I think its better to let admins be chosen based on trust that they will not use it in their own interest.