Wednesday, February 22, 2017

Call for Judgment: Moving back to where I was

Timed out 1 vote to 4. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 24 Feb 2017 18:37:32 UTC

Derrick will be moved back to the forest, nothing having happened since the first illegal action having happened

I misunderstood where days stopped and started. Could I be back in the forest? movement is precious in this game, and my move to the market place was soley a result of an illegal forage attempt.

Comments

Kevan: he/him

22-02-2017 19:08:35 UTC

There’s an unnecessary amount of revoking in the second clause of this - in the mildest case other players’ game actions between now and this CfJ’s enaction will be undone, which seems unfair; under a slightly stronger reading, this CfJ itself will be undone. And with a dedicatedly perverse reading of “since the first illegal action having happened”, we’ll be winding the game back a decade or more.

against You can move again in five hours’ time anyway. And really, your being in a location (the Market) where you can’t take an action because you lack the resources isn’t very different from being in a location (the Forest) where you can’t take an action because you already took it there today. This CfJ could actually give you a free extra move for Thursday, if it took more than five hours to resolve.

Madrid:

22-02-2017 19:35:30 UTC

I doubt the “since the first illegal action having happened” *reading* would pass though, because of consensus reality (it could though, just unlikely because I suspect people would likely just choose the reading that is most convenient to them, which is the more tame interpretation).

But yeah, against on my behalf

orkboi:

22-02-2017 19:57:59 UTC

Not opposed to take-baksies in principle, but I think making mistaken and/or illegal moves in Blognomic and ending up in the wrong place at the wrong time is part of the game. I made a similar UTC blunder earlier in the game which significantly increased my risk of an untimely death. :)

against

pokes:

22-02-2017 21:45:31 UTC

against