Sunday, September 15, 2024

Proposal: Multi-limited

Puzzlers who are not voting AGAINST is less than Quorum, 1-3. Failed by JonathanDark.

Adminned at 16 Sep 2024 13:28:23 UTC

In “Turns” replace “If any of the cells in the currently selected group are part of a Match with another cell that is not in the currently selected group, also select the cells in that Match
” with “If any of the cells in the currently selected group are part of a Match with another cell whose contents are the same of a cell in the original match or a Star and that is not in the currently selected group, also select the cells in that Match, ”

In “Turns” replace “Optionally select the cells of another Match that includes at least one currently selected cell. This step may be repeated any number of times.” with “Optionally select the cells of another Match that includes at least one currently selected cell and whose contents are either the same of a cell in the original match or a Star. This step may be repeated any number of times”

I think chaining multi-matches with a star to let you select different types is probably a bit too strong so making it so that your entire multi-match must be of the same type (or a star)

Comments

JonathanDark: he/him

15-09-2024 05:42:45 UTC

Makes sense

Lukas:

15-09-2024 06:35:05 UTC

The proposal “Optional Multi-Matches” will change the text you reference, so you’ll need to rewrite this for it to have any effect.

Clucky: Puzzle Master he/him

15-09-2024 06:49:57 UTC

good catch

Desertfrog:

15-09-2024 14:43:41 UTC

against with Fewer Stars already making stars less common I think this would make them too weak

JonathanDark: he/him

15-09-2024 21:30:47 UTC

I’m on the fence about this myself. I’d like to see how Fewer Stars plays out first. After another round of play, I wouldn’t be opposed to revisiting this.

Benbot: he/him

16-09-2024 00:35:51 UTC

against see what desert frog said.

Lukas:

16-09-2024 04:27:08 UTC

I’m with JonathanDark here; will wait to see how another round plays out.

JonathanDark: he/him

16-09-2024 04:28:13 UTC

Probably should just go ahead and against