Saturday, January 23, 2010

Proposal: Murderes and Detectives doesnt know Cartlesham Manor

Self-killed. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 25 Jan 2010 06:47:17 UTC

Replace

As above, except this action may only be taken by the Detectives, the Murderers and the Servants, who all have a better knowledge of Cartlesham Manor.

in Rule 2.6 “Lights” with

As above, except this action may only be taken by the the Servants, who have a better knowledge of Cartlesham Manor.

This Proposal is not depending on the status of the Proposal “Servants and gods part 2”.

Quote by There: “Takes away the point of allowing the murderers and detectives to move floors in the dark. If any of them aren’t servants, then it is a give away.” I agree to him.

posted by Keba at 23 Jan 2010 22:15:16 UTC Comments (9)

Comments

alethiophile:

23-01-2010 22:39:06 UTC

against It makes sense thematically, and werewolf-type games need the hidden people to have various powers.

Klisz:

23-01-2010 22:40:28 UTC

for  Though I note that the title should be “Murderes and Detectives don’t know Cartlesham Manor”.

Klisz:

23-01-2010 22:40:56 UTC

CoV against  per alethiophile.

Anonyman:

23-01-2010 22:50:40 UTC

imperial

Kevan: he/him

23-01-2010 22:55:00 UTC

I’m concerned this would make it too easy to completely rule out non-Servant suspects - whenever there’s an attack, then every non-Servant on every other floor must be innocent of it. (Although that doesn’t mean they aren’t a murderer, just that they didn’t commit that particular murder. But if there are two attacks in one period of darkness, then two or three entire floors can be confirmed as murderer-free.) It should be harder work to prove someone innocent, than simple taking turns to hide in the attic.

against

Rodlen:

23-01-2010 23:00:14 UTC

against

Keba:

23-01-2010 23:04:17 UTC

against S/K i see Kevans point.

TrumanCapote:

24-01-2010 02:52:26 UTC

against

digibomber:

25-01-2010 04:15:49 UTC

against