Friday, January 05, 2024

Call for Judgment: New Corpses

Timed out, 0-3. Failed by JonathanDark.

Adminned at 07 Jan 2024 21:26:51 UTC

If the Call for Judgement “No New Corpses” was enacted, this Call for Judgement has no effect.

Uphold the revision of the Ruleset made by Desertfrog on the 5th of January (linked in the CfJ “No New Corpses”).

In the rule “Locations”, replace “The Effects of a Location only apply to a Necromancer if they have that Location” with

The Effects of a Location only apply to a Necromancer if they have that Location, unless the Effects explicitly state that a described action may be done by any Necromancer.

The opposite interpretation, which I think makes more sense from a game design perspective

Comments

Clucky: he/him

05-01-2024 21:36:21 UTC

against

doesn’t matter what people think makes more sense from a game design perspective, rules need to be properly followed.

Josh: he/they

06-01-2024 09:21:31 UTC

for I unidle; quorum is unchanged.

JonathanDark: he/him

07-01-2024 08:58:06 UTC

I would vote against this, but we need a resolution one way or the other, and if this is favored, even by a little, then it might as well go this way and have the rules be more clear.

JonathanDark: he/him

07-01-2024 08:58:34 UTC

However, if someone else votes in favor of “No New Corpses”, then I will vote against this one.

Josh: he/they

07-01-2024 11:16:41 UTC

CoV against

Desertfrog:

07-01-2024 11:41:00 UTC

Withdrawn against because of potential problems Josh pointed out, and a proposal would anyway probably be better for this

JonathanDark: he/him

07-01-2024 21:26:12 UTC

CfJs can’t be withdrawn, but your CoV effectively kills it anyway.