Monday, March 02, 2015

Proposal: No, After You

Reached a Super Quorum, 13 votes to 0, and can be enacted out of sequence. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 04 Mar 2015 19:05:27 UTC

Reword “Contingent Proposals” from “If a proposal starts with the text “Dependent on X”, where X is the name of a proposal or a list of proposals, if any of those proposals fails, the Dependent proposal is considered to be Self-Killed.” to:-

If a Proposal (the “Dependent Proposal”) starts with the text “Dependent on X”, where X is the name of a proposal or a list of proposals (the “Higher” proposal or proposals), then:

  • The Dependent Proposal cannot be enacted if any of its Higher Proposals have not been enacted.
  • If any of its Higher proposals have failed, the Dependent proposal is considered to be Self-Killed.

Seems odd that an explicitly Dependent proposal can - with a Super Quorum of votes - actually end up enacting ahead of the Proposals it is depending on.

Comments

Josh:

03-02-2015 16:54:54 UTC

for

Sylphrena:

03-02-2015 17:11:00 UTC

for

Ely:

03-02-2015 17:21:25 UTC

for

ayesdeeef:

03-02-2015 18:22:14 UTC

for

Maldor:

03-02-2015 20:43:22 UTC

for this makes sense with the super quorum rules

Brendan:

03-02-2015 20:53:44 UTC

for

Darknight:

03-02-2015 20:54:32 UTC

for

mideg:

03-02-2015 21:44:33 UTC

for Good catch!

Teninten:

03-03-2015 01:01:42 UTC

for

Purplebeard:

03-03-2015 10:38:11 UTC

for

RaichuKFM:

03-03-2015 21:50:47 UTC

for

Murphy:

03-04-2015 06:17:46 UTC

for