Monday, October 31, 2011

Proposal: No Reverting Proxy-SKs

Times out and fails, 11-4. -Bucky

Adminned at 01 Nov 2011 21:26:25 UTC

REPRESENTING: ais523, Chronos Phaenon, southpointingchariot, Amnistar
In the rule “Downsizing”, change the text

The Employee’s vote shall be counted as DEF on that Proposal.

to

The Employee’s vote shall be counted as DEF on that Proposal, unless they are Represented by that proposal.

Credit to ais523 for spotting this; If your proposal represents one of your employees and that employee self-kills it, you can fire him to keep it from being self-killed.  Furthermore, if something like Rent-a-Proposal passes, your employer can adopt your self-killed proposal and fire you to un-self-kill it.

posted by Bucky at 31 Oct 2011 02:28:24 UTC Comments (16)

Comments

scshunt:

31-10-2011 02:38:48 UTC

against

Murphy:

31-10-2011 03:23:50 UTC

for

Amnistar: he/him

31-10-2011 03:39:58 UTC

for

omd:

31-10-2011 03:46:21 UTC

This is a feature, not a bug: hiring someone is difficult enough that it won’t have much of an effect either way, but if this tactic is applicable in some situation it would be an interesting option.

against

Spitemaster:

31-10-2011 04:29:35 UTC

against

arthexis: he/him

31-10-2011 05:02:11 UTC

against per comex

Prince Anduril:

31-10-2011 08:02:43 UTC

against

SingularByte: he/him

31-10-2011 08:44:10 UTC

against

ais523:

31-10-2011 10:16:37 UTC

for because if I make a bona fide attempt to fix this bug, I won’t feel so bad about exploiting it later

ChronosPhaenon:

31-10-2011 13:36:32 UTC

against SK votes can’t be changed anyway.

Pavitra:

31-10-2011 16:27:12 UTC

against per comex.

ais523:

31-10-2011 16:54:06 UTC

@Chronos: Dynastic overrides core.

southpointingchariot:

31-10-2011 17:32:20 UTC

imperial per comex

lazerchik:

01-11-2011 03:08:40 UTC

against

Darknight: he/him

01-11-2011 04:58:41 UTC

against

Ornithopter:

01-11-2011 05:39:32 UTC

against