Monday, November 19, 2007

Proposal: No Room on the Bus

Cannot reach quorum without change of votes 1 - 10 Failed by Chivalrybean

Adminned at 19 Nov 2007 23:33:47 UTC

Add a new dynastic rule (or subrule), entitled: “Limitations on Number of Einherjar”, as follows:

Any Einherjar that has been recruited by a Valkyrie and that has not been removed from that Valkyrie’s section of the “Einherjar” wiki page is deemed to be in that Valkyrie’s Portfolio.
No Valkyrie may have more than five (5) Einherjar in her Portfolio at any time.  No Valkyrie may have more than three (3) Einherjar in her Portfolio that share the same Gender.

Add a new subrule entitled: “Trades”, as follows:

Valkyries may transfer any of their Einherjar to any other Valkyrie by posting a story post that announces the transfers.  Transfers may be made conditional on another transfer being made (for example, Valkyrie “X” may announce “I transfer Einherjar “A” to Valkyrie “Y”, conditioned upon Valkyrie “Y” transferring Einherjar “B” and “C” to me.)  An unconditional transfer is effective when announced; a conditional transfer is effective as soon as the condition is satisfied.

The idea being that one should think carefully about “filling up slots” in the Portfolio, rather than grabbing any Einherjar that becomes available).


Amnistar: he/him

19-11-2007 16:46:06 UTC

I’d rather that it be more of a balance issue, total stats for all einherjar must be a certain amount, or something.

Amnistar: he/him

19-11-2007 16:50:48 UTC

or perhaps, each valkerie has a number of “portfolio slots” tracked in the GDNT which can be gained or lost via acorn exchange…

Kevan: he/him

19-11-2007 16:56:34 UTC



19-11-2007 17:01:22 UTC

So, I can transfer without the consent of the other Valkyrie? So, I can recruit some crappy ones, and then give them to people who don’t want them?

I would suggest that the receiving Valkyrie would have to vote For in the comments to approve first.

against , until fixed. Otherwise I’d vote yet.


19-11-2007 17:03:43 UTC

That’s a good suggestion, Chiv.  I will post a fix.


19-11-2007 17:09:15 UTC

imperial COV

Amnistar: he/him

19-11-2007 17:53:30 UTC

Not really a fan, but if the Allfather wants it…


19-11-2007 18:23:00 UTC

against Not a fan of a hard limit.  You should be able to choose whether to focus on getting a few expensive Einherjar, or many inexpensive Einherjar.

Kevan: he/him

19-11-2007 18:25:33 UTC

against  against CoV as per Hix, acorns are already a good enough limit.


19-11-2007 19:36:04 UTC

against trades might be ok, so long as we can also transfer acorns (or anything else that might be of value later)


19-11-2007 23:39:41 UTC



19-11-2007 23:40:49 UTC

imperial ->  against

Darknight: he/him

20-11-2007 01:19:03 UTC


Oracular rufio:

20-11-2007 05:55:42 UTC