Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Proposal: Once more, with bleach

Times out and fails 6-3.  -2 to arthexis.  -Bucky

Adminned at 23 Oct 2009 14:23:44 UTC

Create a new rule “Victory Coalition”:

For each Team, there is a number known as a Team Score, which is equal to the Score of all the Players of that Team, plus 20 for each rule owned by that Team. When the Team Score of a Team is equal to or greater than 500 AND each Player belonging to that Team has a Score of at least 100, the Player belonging to that Team who has the highest Score amongst that Team has achieved victory.

Change rule Victory Coalition so that it is no longer owned by any team.

If at least half the EVCs on this proposal contain the text “sporting chance”, each Player is awarded 20 points.

Now with even less color!

Comments

Bucky:

10-21-2009 21:15:32 UTC

for .  I will change my vote to AGAINST if the rider looks like it’s going to pass.

Kevan:

10-21-2009 21:26:11 UTC

for

Klisz:

10-21-2009 21:31:13 UTC

for sporting chance

Darknight:

10-21-2009 22:08:56 UTC

for

Ienpw III:

10-22-2009 01:00:24 UTC

against Sporting Chance.
This still gives an unfair advantage to teams with more players.

arthexis:

10-22-2009 01:24:26 UTC

Ok, I won’t include the rider either, unless it becomes highly popular. @yuri: your team is the one with most players, so that kinda benefits you.

Ienpw III:

10-22-2009 02:24:39 UTC

... CoV for
Thanks arth ;)

Josh:

10-22-2009 11:04:35 UTC

for Sporting chance.

spikebrennan:

10-22-2009 13:49:23 UTC

for Sporting Chance

Oze:

10-22-2009 14:55:44 UTC

for Sporting Chance

Klisz:

10-22-2009 15:15:32 UTC

CoV against

Qwazukee:

10-22-2009 16:40:01 UTC

against sporting chance

Klisz:

10-22-2009 21:56:58 UTC

RoV against  sporting chance

Bucky:

10-23-2009 00:27:57 UTC

CoV against for the reason described with my original vote.

ais523:

10-23-2009 07:46:26 UTC

against sporting chance

Kevan:

10-23-2009 08:43:46 UTC

against CoV per Bucky. As ever, “if half the EVCs” is not a consequence-free extra proposal.

Oze:

10-23-2009 15:37:55 UTC

against CoV