Monday, November 03, 2008

Proposal: One Tradition per Proposal

reached quorum, final vote 10-0—Yoda

Adminned at 05 Nov 2008 12:46:28 UTC

Replace the text

Whenever a proposal creates a new Tradition as part of being enacted, the Clansmen who proposed it may, within 24 hours of the enactment, increase their Honor by 2 once.

in rule 2.10 with

Whenever a proposal creates a new Tradition, or new Traditions, as part of being enacted, the Clansmen who proposed it may, within 24 hours of the enactment, increase their Honor by 2 once, regardless of the number of traditions created in the proposal.

Add the text

The Plant Spirit Sunra has declared that no Clansman may hunt the same type of animal three times in a row.

to the list of Barbarian Traditions

I felt it was ambiguous whether or not multiple traditions in a single proposal would allow honor to be increased multiple times.

Comments

Bucky:

03-11-2008 22:48:06 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

03-11-2008 23:19:42 UTC

for

arthexis: he/him

03-11-2008 23:22:56 UTC

for

Rodlen:

04-11-2008 02:58:51 UTC

for

Yoda:

04-11-2008 03:09:52 UTC

against I create 0 traditions.  0 is a number and the rule says regardless of the number of traditions created.

arthexis: he/him

04-11-2008 05:53:51 UTC

However the rule starts with “Whenever a proposal creates a new Tradition, or new Traditions” which implies one or more. Otherwise, no new traditions would be created and the sentence would make no sense.

Yoda:

04-11-2008 06:03:36 UTC

... ok. for cov

Hello Sailor:

04-11-2008 14:46:14 UTC

for

Purplebeard:

04-11-2008 20:33:51 UTC

for

Dustin:

05-11-2008 17:17:17 UTC

for

Clucky: he/him

05-11-2008 20:31:49 UTC

for