Monday, May 30, 2011

Call for Judgment: Out-Of-Season Harvesting

Timed out 7-7.—Yoda

Adminned at 03 Jun 2011 16:41:28 UTC

It seems that coppro harvested twice last week (as well as a third time, which has been reverted by Ely), on both the 23th and the 28th. I’d revert it directly, but they’ve spent most of the Sun they gained from the second harvest, hence this CfJ.

coppro gained 160 from the illegal harvest, and spent 150 on a shed and two sunflowers.

Therefore, if this Call for Judgment passes, decrease the Sun of the Farmer named coppro by 10 and remove a shed and two Sunflowers from their Plot. If no shed is on their plot, remove three sunflowers from it instead. If coppro had less than 10 Sun at the time this is enacted (and before its effects take place), remove the crop with the lowest Sun Cost from their plot.

Comments

SingularByte:

05-30-2011 08:03:20 UTC

for

scshunt:

05-30-2011 08:46:31 UTC

Right, so, I just fail.

for

Ely:

05-30-2011 10:15:35 UTC

for

qwertyu63:

05-30-2011 14:22:58 UTC

for

Josh:

05-30-2011 15:17:41 UTC

for

Bucky:

05-30-2011 15:40:53 UTC

for

ais523:

05-30-2011 16:52:09 UTC

Err, if the actions were illegal, didn’t they not happen in the first place? In that case, trying to revert them could be problematic.

Winner:

05-30-2011 20:24:18 UTC

for

aguydude:

05-30-2011 20:54:50 UTC

for Since this hurts coppro and he voted for it, I’ll assume the CfJ is accurate.

Ely:

05-30-2011 21:11:17 UTC

[ais]
Right, actually we should “revert” those without CfJ, since the GNDT and the Garden Patch no longer reflect the Gamestate. If this CfJ passes, I’m afraid this will overpunish the poor coppro, since the not-gamestatey Sunflowers do not exist and thus may not be removed. So, let’s get the real one. Mmmh, I’m not sure if this makes sense, my head hurts.
Any thought?

Yoda:

05-30-2011 22:23:15 UTC

against Yah, I think this just needs to be reverted since the documents no longer represent Gamestate.  Basically, these CfJs should just act as a warning for coppro not to try to cheat any more.

qwertyu63:

05-31-2011 01:59:29 UTC

CoV against per Ely

Ely:

05-31-2011 06:30:38 UTC

against per Ely, and I’ll revert those myself. CfJ me if you don’t think so. We’ve not had enough CfJ’s this dynasty.

scshunt:

06-01-2011 01:44:56 UTC

I don’t know.

Doctor29:

06-01-2011 02:31:23 UTC

for

Darknight:

06-01-2011 03:14:21 UTC

for

Purplebeard:

06-01-2011 09:17:53 UTC

against No sense in reverting it twice.

qwertyu63:

06-01-2011 17:09:51 UTC

CoV against

mideg:

06-03-2011 07:50:00 UTC

against I don’t really understand everything yet, but I believe Ely’s argumentation is sound, so.

Yoda:

06-03-2011 14:51:02 UTC

Current vote count that I have is 8-5.

Winner:

06-03-2011 21:45:28 UTC

against

Galtori:

06-03-2011 23:40:32 UTC

against