Tuesday, October 11, 2016

Proposal: Politicalculus

Times out and passes 3-0. Enacted by Brendan.

Adminned at 13 Oct 2016 17:42:38 UTC

Change the first two bullets in the rule “Gerrymander” to:

  • A Constituency may not have fewer than 8 blocks.
  • A Constituency may not have more than 12 blocks.

Because of the way this is phrased, I keep getting it wrong, and I’m not the only one.

Comments

Matt:

10-11-2016 18:17:57 UTC

for This expands the valid range from 9-11 to 8-12.

Kevan:

10-11-2016 22:44:21 UTC

for Just wording it as “Each Constituency must have between 8 and 12 blocks” would be clearer still.

Matt:

10-11-2016 22:46:07 UTC

Kevan, that would again open the issue of whether 8 and 12 are inclusive as “between 8 and 12”.