Thursday, April 02, 2020

Proposal: Power Corrupts

Enacted 9-1. Josh

Adminned at 03 Apr 2020 18:23:39 UTC

In the rule “Victory Score” after “A Nobleman gains 2 VIctory Score points for every Item that they have in their Estate. ” add the line “A Nobleman loses 1 Victory Score for every point of Power below zero that they have”


Fixing a potential game breaking problem. Will explain more in the comments.


Clucky: he/him

02-04-2020 00:17:28 UTC

So the current auction system is kinda bugged, but exploiting the bug only gives you a small advantage when you exploit it you need to keep exploiting it for several auctions to actually really use and after the first attempt, the jig will be up and the entire dynasty will likely break down.

Basically, the only negative side effect to your power going super low is that you lose a prestige a day. And then people can start stealing your items. But if you win ever auction you’ll probably still come out a head.

With money, if you spend enormous amounts you run the risk of going Dissolute and can’t win. But you your power could be the negative value of grahm’s number can you can still technically win as long as you have enough items. Weighted Power Factor won’t effect anything because you can bid numbers so large the WPF won’t matter. The only way to counter someone who decides to ignore their power and just win every item is to bid more power than they do. And so the end result would be people figuring out how to bid the highest number possible. Which isn’t fun for anyone and goes against the spirit of the dynasty.

With this in place, someone could still technically sandbag. But I think the likelihood of someone doing that is a lot lower as there isn’t any real reason to do it. Whereas today, trying to bid the max power feels to me like it would probably actually be the optimal strategy.


02-04-2020 05:20:26 UTC


Kevan: Oracle he/him

02-04-2020 09:02:13 UTC


Josh: he/him

02-04-2020 09:45:45 UTC


Darknight: he/him

02-04-2020 10:09:01 UTC



02-04-2020 14:33:59 UTC



02-04-2020 15:55:31 UTC


Tantusar: he/they

02-04-2020 15:59:18 UTC

against a bit selfish of me but such is how it is

pencilgame: he/him

02-04-2020 17:26:08 UTC


Brendan: he/him

02-04-2020 17:41:43 UTC