Proposal: Prevent Brendan winning by default
Timed out / quorumed 8 votes to 1. Enacted by Kevan.
(Note by ais523: you miscounted, it’s actually 3 votes to 1. This does not change anything about the enactment, because it was already timed out.)
Adminned at 16 Feb 2015 11:50:06 UTC
In the rule “Clearance”, replace
When a Crewmember is part of the Responder Team for a Mission that succeeds, their Clearance increases by 2. When a Crewmember is part of the Responder Team for a Mission that fails, their Clearance decreases by 3. If the Pilot posted a Roster Comment on a Mission, instead, none of its Responder Team gains or loses Clearance as a result of that Mission.
with
When a Crewmember is part of the Responder Team for a Mission that succeeds, their Clearance increases by 2. When a Crewmember is part of the Responder Team for a Mission that fails, their Clearance decreases by 3. If the Pilot posted a Roster Comment on a Mission, none of those Clearance changes happen for that Mission; instead, when a Mission succeeds for which the Pilot posted a Roster Comment, then the Pilot’s Clearance increases by 3.
Currently, the only players who can even potentially get the Human victory are Brendan and Josh (and Josh is almost certainly an Android, leaving it as just Brendan). This is because the only Clearance decreasers around are Mission failure (which Brendan has veto power over), and Mediator effects.
The intent behind this proposal is to prevent Brendan gaining an advantage from use of the Mediator power; because he a gets 3-point advantage over the mission team when a mission is Rostered (let’s face it, the only correct move is to Sabotage for the Clearance gain), this gives him a 3-point disadvantage to cancel it out.
Bucky:
There is a flaw in your logic.![against](https://blognomic.com/images/vote/against.gif)