Friday, July 16, 2010

Call for Judgment: Proposal During Hiatus

Fails with a quorum against. (3-9) - lilomar (sorry, put this in the wrong box the first time)

Adminned at 20 Jul 2010 05:47:28 UTC

In the “Keywords” section of the glossary, change the definition of Quorum to:

Quorum is equal to half the number of @s, rounded down, plus one.

Comments

Qwazukee:

07-16-2010 06:01:16 UTC

for

Josh: HE/HIM

07-16-2010 06:17:46 UTC

for

Josh: HE/HIM

07-16-2010 08:06:39 UTC

Although I’m not sure that I approve of using CfJs as a way of circumventing haitus rules.

Purplebeard:

07-16-2010 08:07:33 UTC

for

Ienpw III:

07-16-2010 11:29:01 UTC

against

lilomar:

07-16-2010 12:26:14 UTC

Abstain Per Josh’s second comment. I will vote for this if it comes up in a Proposal after Hiatus.

Klisz:

07-16-2010 13:01:28 UTC

for

spikebrennan:

07-16-2010 13:16:11 UTC

Idle AGAINST.  The old quorum definition could use a patch, but this throws out some useful concepts.

dbdougla:

07-16-2010 14:28:05 UTC

Also, doesn’t a literal interpretation of this include idle @‘s?  (this has bothered me for a while)

dbdougla:

07-16-2010 14:29:32 UTC

Nvm, sorry, I just saw the “except in certain rules where they aren’t counted” clause.

Put:

07-16-2010 15:18:55 UTC

against

ais523:

07-16-2010 17:50:10 UTC

for as a stopgap so that we know what the gamestate is. This is better than the current definition, after all; as an extra proposal will be needed to change to a third definition anyway, we may as well have a better definition in the interim.

Bucky:

07-16-2010 19:28:14 UTC

for

lilomar:

07-17-2010 02:30:00 UTC

for

Darknight: HE/HIM

07-17-2010 03:16:15 UTC

for

lilomar:

07-17-2010 16:47:18 UTC

Still for as a stop-gap. I have submitted a full-reworking of the original definition here: http://blognomic.com/archive/since_i_started_this_mess/

Bucky:

07-19-2010 02:54:39 UTC

CoV against

dbdougla:

07-19-2010 06:00:56 UTC

imperial

lilomar:

07-19-2010 13:53:17 UTC

CoV against

Purplebeard:

07-19-2010 14:32:27 UTC

against

Galdyn:

07-19-2010 19:24:53 UTC

against

Qwazukee:

07-19-2010 23:39:17 UTC

CoV against

ais523:

07-19-2010 23:57:47 UTC

against due to a better change passing via proposal.