Monday, September 08, 2014

Proposal: Proposal: There is but one goalkeeper

Self-Killed. -RaichuKFM

Adminned at 09 Sep 2014 12:42:27 UTC

Amend rule “Kicking the Ball” by substituting for the text:

If the result is 2, ownership of the Ball is transferred to a Player of the same position as the target Player, chosen randomly using the GNDT. If the result is 3, the Ball becomes Out of Play and is removed from any Player’s possession.

the text:

If the result is 2 and there exists at least one Player with the same position as the target Player, ownership of the Ball is transferred to such a Player, chosen randomly using the GNDT amongst all Players with that position. Otherwise, the Ball becomes Out of Play and is removed from any Player’s possession.

Proposal proposal.

posted by Cpt_Koen at 08 Sep 2014 20:37:26 UTC Comments (6)

Comments

BellEt:

09-09-2014 06:32:54 UTC

I don’t see the necessity imperial

Kevan: Concierge he/him

09-09-2014 06:58:12 UTC

Not sure this does anything. There will always be one player with the same position as any given player: the player themselves. This needs to say “one other player”.

Sylphrena:

09-09-2014 13:35:20 UTC

for  Kevan: You can kick to someone in a different position. eg, you someone can kick to the goalkeeper, despite the fact that there is a maximum of one goalkeeper.

Also: Now that our Coach has idled, how do we do anything that requires a coach (like resolving deferrals)?

Kevan: Concierge he/him

09-09-2014 13:44:18 UTC

If you Kick to the Goalkeeper under the current rule, “ownership of the Ball is transferred to a Player of the same position as the target Player”, and that’s still the Goalkeeper. The Goalkeeper has the same position as his or herself.

Deferentials are uncounted abstentions in the absence of a Coach - it’s up to us whether we bring in a rule saying how to resolve them, or just refrain from using them.

RaichuKFM: she/her

09-09-2014 16:45:12 UTC

Yeah, as far as I can tell, this is redundant.

Cpt_Koen:

09-09-2014 17:22:34 UTC

against Self-kill; didn’t realize the target Player had the same position as themselves!