I’m a little leery of the “all” in there - there’s a lot of stuff that’s meaningless, and which would be labourious to compile (DM back-chatter with players, the specific wording of PMs).

I’m only keeping a summary log, which I’m happy to share at the end of the dynasty, although I will of course vote DEF on this to allow Electors to chose to protect their privacy if they wish. (I do note that Cuddlebeam is the requestor, here; Cuddlebeam, who has promised permanent grudges to anyone who ever betrays him.)

Editted it to “Summary”.

And yeah, the ‘grudges’ is just avoidance and carefulness when making alliances, not outright revenge. It’s not as tragically severe as it seems, but I do want to underline that I will behave that way.

This is too vague. If someone PMs Josh to say “change my Secret Faction again because I don’t trust X, and we both know Y is unreliable after what happened in that other dynasty, also happy birthday for Thursday”, how much of that secret sentence is this rule actually asking him to reveal? I’d rather see the plainer “when X happens, note this down” debug log suggested in Meet Me At The Shooting Range.

I’m not sure there’s really that much interdynastic information at stake here: Josh can only see some game actions, with no context for why they were taken. Secret information dynasties often end with the Emperor having had no idea who knew what, or how someone suddenly won. The real insights will be in the secret player backchannels.

That’s pretty sus, Kevan.

It’s just a summary.