Sunday, December 13, 2009

Proposal: Release

Adminned at 14 Dec 2009 07:11:27 UTC

Add the following to rule 2.4, Djinni in a lamp, baby:

If an Adventurer causes the Djinni to be released from the lamp, that Adventurer gains 3 more wishes, unless that Adventurer caused the Djinni to enter the lamp.

Self-killed, final vote 7 for - 5 against

Comments

Klisz:

13-12-2009 19:35:16 UTC

for  But remember to fix the typo “Djinni” (should be “Djinn”).

redtara: they/them

13-12-2009 19:38:07 UTC

Uh… there’s a problem with the ruleset.
“Djinni” is singular.
“Djinn” is plural.

Klisz:

13-12-2009 19:38:58 UTC

Doesn’t matter, really.

Kevan: he/him

13-12-2009 19:44:11 UTC

for

SingularByte: he/him

13-12-2009 19:49:43 UTC

for

Josh: Observer he/they

13-12-2009 19:51:12 UTC

for

Klisz:

13-12-2009 19:56:02 UTC

CoV imperial  I’d rather leave this up to Wak.

Ornithopter:

13-12-2009 20:06:02 UTC

for

Bucky:

13-12-2009 20:33:10 UTC

for

tecslicer:

13-12-2009 20:35:17 UTC

for

Wakukee:

13-12-2009 20:38:59 UTC

Is there any way TO realease the Djinn? Personally, I wanted to give only 3 wishes and make others very hard to get. I would prefer to give a single wish for release.  against

Qwazukee:

13-12-2009 21:10:46 UTC

for

redtara: they/them

13-12-2009 21:52:59 UTC

Three wishes are traditional.
And there’s no point in setting /everything/ up now: this is a nomic.
And who says releasing the Djinni is easy?

alethiophile:

13-12-2009 22:18:51 UTC

An ambiguity: ‘unless that Adventurer caused the Djinni to enter the Lamp’ might trigger if the Adventurer has ever caused the Djinni to enter the lamp, while unless I miss my guess the exemption is meant to prevent people from putting the Djinni into the Lamp and immediately getting him out again to farm wishes. (I can’t vote yet, but when I unidle I’ll vote against, in favor of one with a similar clause reading “unless that Adventurer was the last to cause the Djinni to enter the Lamp”).

Darknight: he/him

13-12-2009 22:28:21 UTC

against Per Al

redtara: they/them

13-12-2009 22:53:28 UTC

S/K against per Al.

Nausved:

14-12-2009 05:45:10 UTC

imperial