Proposal: Score Board
Revisable, 0-0 with 4 REVISE votes. Failed-revise by JonathanDark.
Adminned at 18 May 2025 18:45:09 UTC
Add a rule named “Scoring” with the following text:
Each Drafter has a publicly tracked number named Score that defaults to 0 and must be between 0 and 10.
As a Daily Action called a Scoring, a Drafter may select a Drafter other than themselves who has a non-blank Plan Link, and then increase or decrease the selected Drafter’s Score by 1, provided the resulting Score is a legal value. A Drafter’s Score may not be decreased from a performance of a Scoring more than once in a 24-hour period.
Any time a Drafter’s Plan Link is changed, that Drafter’s Score is reset to 0.
A simple method for scoring Plans, with protection against piling on one Drafter to decrease their score too quickly. If people want to pile on to increase one Drafter’s score quickly, that’s perfectly acceptable.
ais523: Supervisor
I am worried that making this a daily would give an excessive advantage to people who can be online all the time to grind, especially as players don’t necessarily have to be voting based on Plan merit.
The basic idea of having subjective scoring of Plans is fine, but we may need to think more about the details.
(Additionally, players can and usually will update their Plan by editing the existing page, rather than linking to a different page.)