Saturday, February 04, 2017

Proposal: Secure Trade (c)(tm)

Fails 3-3. — Quirck

Adminned at 06 Feb 2017 13:24:30 UTC

Add to “Stories” in “Remedies”

If two villagers privately inform the doctor that they wish to listen to the other’s family tale, the doctor should privately reply to the two villagers with the information contained in the other villager’s family tale (i.e. a remedy and its effect).

Comments

Kevan: he/him

04-02-2017 19:44:04 UTC

:DEF: A network of trust and misinformation seems more interesting.

Also, it’s unclear what happens if one or both of the Villagers haven’t yet requested to recall a story - the stories are only created when the “recall” action is taken.

Kevan: he/him

04-02-2017 19:44:27 UTC

By which vote I mean imperial

Viv:

04-02-2017 23:06:44 UTC

Hmmm… against

derrick: he/him

05-02-2017 00:27:52 UTC

against This puts all the effort on the Doctor. Some mechanic would be nice, but I’ve been in similar situations before (game master of a game with hidden info in Play by Post) and this is an unhealthy idea.

pokes:

05-02-2017 14:04:57 UTC

for

Matt:

05-02-2017 19:57:13 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

05-02-2017 23:08:02 UTC

against CoV, have just realised the proposed action is actually impossible because I haven’t been recording the stories I’ve given out so far (only the fact that certain players have received them).