“shall be determined by the narrator secretly and randomly” is going to end up in a weird place, I think. The appendices require random selections to be “from a uniform probability distribution over the entire range of possible values”, and given that Idle Sailors are counted as Sailors for goal definitions, that gives us a thousand Goals which are “protect/kill an idle player”, compared to a couple of dozen which aren’t.

“the Sailor whose Goals have the highest total Worth” is almost certainly going to be 10, because the original Goal-picking rule allowed Sailors to take a selection of total Worth 10. (If you’re trying to measure the total score for completed Goals, this isn’t doing it, it’s just measuring the potential score for Goals.)

(And good to see caution over inconsistent formatting, but BlogNomic has never been case-sensitive in applying its rules, so don’t worry.)

You’re allowed to edit a proposal for exactly 2 hours after posting it, so long as nobody has cast a voting icon on it, so feel free to make some changes.

As I read it, this is is just going to give new players a random mix of 10 protect/kill idle player goals, which will most likely be impossible (as these players were neither Alive nor Dead at the time they went idle).

Ah, my mistake there, I didn’t read the proposal as having been edited, and it looks like it just squeaked through before card’s vote.

but all Goals except Avenge Nature are resolved “at the end of the Story”, so won’t have been completed yet.