Friday, February 03, 2017

Proposal: Self-Cure

Self-killed. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 04 Feb 2017 16:00:37 UTC

Upon enacting this proposal, change the Game State to remove the Symptom of Death from the Doctor.

Some N/A rules and actions cannot be performed without the doctor’s participation.

Comments

Madrid:

03-02-2017 09:29:46 UTC

He’s just going to die again anyways, because the only method of Death is the Black Death.

I guess this could allow you to try to enact your “Cough Medicine” item consumption attempt, but not much else than that. This proposal is hardly a solution to the “problem”, and it looks to me to be pretty lop-sided towards your interests (your own item consumption attempt).

Allowing the Doctor to be able to perform his actions is a reasonable proposal imo, but this isn’t the way to do it (unless there is some majority that wants a “temporarily alive” Doctor or something, to keep him denied later on).

Kevan: he/him

03-02-2017 09:38:09 UTC

for Nomic! This needs a permanent (and retroactive) fix, though, I’ve processed a couple of Remedy consumptions without thinking of them as “actions”. I’ll raise a CfJ to see if we can sort it out before today’s Rounds.

pokes:

03-02-2017 12:13:11 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

03-02-2017 13:45:06 UTC

against CoV, no need for this now.

Viv:

03-02-2017 13:53:06 UTC

against give the man a rest

Matt:

03-02-2017 15:42:17 UTC

against s/k, cfj was a better and more swift solution.

Madrid:

04-02-2017 12:43:33 UTC

against aaay

derrick: he/him

04-02-2017 15:29:53 UTC

against Better solutions are available

Kevan: he/him

04-02-2017 16:00:18 UTC

No need to keep voting here - once someone has voted against their own proposal, “this renders the Proposal Self-Killed, even if the author later changes their Vote” and it will always fail.